Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 6 questions

Whether it has any plans to review the law regarding post-mortems, including the right for both the defence and the prosecution to request their own for the purposes of criminal procedure.

Started with S5W-14044 on 24 Jan 2018; latest 6 Mar 2018. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
5
longest chain 2 steps
Span
41 days
24 Jan 2018 to 6 Mar 2018
Answered
6 of 6
by James Wolffe QC, Michael Matheson
Asked by
1
Kezia Dugdale

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S5W-14044 24 Jan 2018 Kezia Dugdale Lab Answered

    To ask the Scottish Government whether it has any plans to review the law regarding post-mortems, including the right for both the defence and the prosecution to request their own for the purposes of criminal procedure.

    Michael Matheson, 31 Jan 2018: In suspicious deaths a post mortem examination is a necessary part of the Crown investigation. In law, the defence have a right to instruct a post mortem examination on behalf on an accused person. "Equality of arms" is a key component of the principle of the right to a fair trial, enshrined in Article 6 of the Europe…
  2. S5W-14316 1 Feb 2018 Kezia Dugdale Lab Answered

    What steps the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal is taking to ensure that the views of (a) families of victims and (b) witnesses will be heard in its review of post-mortem examination protocol.      

    James Wolffe QC, 26 Feb 2018: Post Mortem examination is a necessary step in the investigation of suspicious deaths. In law, the Defence have a right to instruct a defence post mortem examination to properly test the evidence against an accused person. Failure to recognise this right would potentially jeopardise any subsequent criminal proceedings…
  3. S5W-14954 28 Feb 2018 Kezia Dugdale Lab Answered follows S5W-14044

    When it expects the revised Post Mortem Examination Protocol to be published.

    James Wolffe QC, 6 Mar 2018: COPFS is developing a protocol to support effective consultation between pathologists instructed by the Crown and the defence. This work is ongoing. The completion of that work and publication date of any consultation protocol will be informed by the responses from forensic pathologists and consultation with the Law S…
  4. S5W-15125 6 Mar 2018 Kezia Dugdale Lab Answered

    What assessment the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) is making of systems and experiences in other UK nations and countries.

    James Wolffe QC, 21 Mar 2018: The protocol being developed by COPFS is designed to support effective consultation between pathologists instructed by the Crown and the Defence. The focussed nature of the protocol is such that reference to other jurisdictions is not relevant. The work has involved consulting with Forensic pathologists, who are the r…
  5. S5W-15126 6 Mar 2018 Kezia Dugdale Lab Answered follows S5W-14954

    What consideration will be given to the views of victims and witnesses as part of this process and how they are being consulted.

    James Wolffe QC, 20 Mar 2018: The protocol being developed by COPFS is designed to support effective consultation between pathologists instructed by the Crown and the Defence. The focussed nature of the protocol is such that reference to other jurisdictions is not relevant. The work has involved consulting with Forensic pathologists, who are the r…
  6. S5W-15127 6 Mar 2018 Kezia Dugdale Lab Answered follows S5W-14954

    Whether the conclusion and results of the review will be reported to the Parliament.

    James Wolffe QC, 20 Mar 2018: The protocol being developed by COPFS is designed to support effective consultation between pathologists instructed by the Crown and the Defence. The focussed nature of the protocol is such that reference to other jurisdictions is not relevant. The work has involved consulting with Forensic pathologists, who are the r…

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads