Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 7 questions

Whether, following the previous Lord Advocate’s decision in August 2001 to take no criminal proceedings against the Scottish Criminal Record Office experts in respect of their misidentification of the Shirley McKie fing…

Started with S2W-29649 on 7 Nov 2006; latest 1 Feb 2007. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
6
longest chain 3 steps
Span
86 days
7 Nov 2006 to 1 Feb 2007
Answered
7 of 7
by Elish Angiolini
Asked by
1
Alex Neil

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S2W-29649 7 Nov 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive whether, following the previous Lord Advocate’s decision in August 2001 to take no criminal proceedings against the Scottish Criminal Record Office experts in respect of their misidentification of the Shirley McKie fingerprint, those experts were granted immunity from prosecution or whether it would be possible to commence prosecution of the same experts for this misidentification if ne…

    Elish Angiolini, 21 Nov 2006: The decision not to take proceedingsagainst the four SCRO officers who identified print Y7 as being that of ShirleyMcKie, made by the Lord Advocate in 2001, is final and it would not be possibleto prosecute these officers at any point in the future in relation to their identificationof Y7. The finality of the decision…
  2. S2W-30458 7 Dec 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered

    Whether the bar on further proceedings relates only to the Shirley McKie case; whether the names of those experts who cannot now be prosecuted can be provided, and on what date and in what manner these experts were informed that they could no longer be prosecuted.

    Elish Angiolini, 21 Dec 2006: A public announcement was madeon 7 September 2001, confirming that no proceedings were to be taken againstofficers of the Scottish Criminal RecordOffice (SCRO) following allegations of criminalconduct which had been made against them. The officers in question were Hugh MacPherson,Fiona McBride, Charles Stewart and Ant…
  3. S2W-30459 7 Dec 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-29649

    Whether any inquiries have been carried out into either alleged or actual misidentification of fingerprint evidence by the Scottish Criminal Record Office in relation to any crime in the Kilmarnock area, other than in relation to any current proceedings, within the last 20 years and, if so, when and to whom they were reported and what recommendations were made.

    Elish Angiolini, 21 Dec 2006: I refer the member to the answer to question S2W-30463 on 21 December 2006. All answers to writtenparliamentary questions are available on the Parliament’s website the search facilityfor which can be found at http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/webapp/wa.search.
  4. S2W-30463 8 Dec 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-29649

    Whether there are any inquiries currently under way into either alleged or actual misidentification of fingerprint evidence by the Scottish Criminal Record Office in relation to any crime in the Kilmarnock area and, if so, how many.

    Elish Angiolini, 21 Dec 2006: In 2003, inquiries were carriedout into the fingerprint evidence provided by the Scottish Criminal Record Office(SCRO) in the case against Mark Sinclair, which arose in the Kilmarnock area.The Crown did not use the fingerprint evidence provided by SCRO on that occasion. In 2006, the fingerprint evidenceprovided by SCR…
  5. S2W-31044 16 Jan 2007 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-30458

    Whether the Crown could not raise criminal proceedings against any of the officers concerned even if new evidence came to light.

    Elish Angiolini, 31 Jan 2007: In Scots Law, when a decisionto take no proceedings has been intimated by the Crown to a person against whoma criminal allegation is made, the Crown are held to it, and such intimation isregarded by the court as constituting a bar to any proceedings thereafter. Thisrule applies even where new evidence comes to light a…
  6. S2W-31045 16 Jan 2007 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-30458

    On what basis and on whose authority the decision was made that no proceedings were to be taken against officers of the Scottish Criminal Record Office.

    Elish Angiolini, 31 Jan 2007: The decision not to raise proceedingsagainst the four Scottish Criminal Record Office officers against whom criminalallegations were made was taken by the former Lord Advocate, Lord Boyd, in 2001.A public announcement of this decision was made in September 2001. The decision was taken on thebasis that there was insuff…
  7. S2W-31601 1 Feb 2007 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-31044

    Whether a charge of perverting the course of justice would be appropriate in respect of the actions of the SCRO experts if evidence came to light that their evidence given at any trial or inquiry or in any report was false.

    Elish Angiolini, 14 Feb 2007: I am not aware of any such evidencebeing available. Accordingly, I do not consider it appropriate to speculate on thismatter.

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads