Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 7 questions

Whether it has any views on the advice given to the All-Party Group on Extraordinary Rendition at Westminster by the Centre for Human Rights and Global Justice of New York University School of Law that “seemingly innocu…

Started with S2W-21768 on 14 Dec 2005; latest 24 Mar 2006. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
6
longest chain 3 steps
Span
100 days
14 Dec 2005 to 24 Mar 2006
Answered
7 of 7
by Colin Boyd
Asked by
1
Alex Neil

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S2W-21768 14 Dec 2005 Alex Neil SNP Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive whether it has any views on the advice given to the All-Party Group on Extraordinary Rendition at Westminster by the Centre for Human Rights and Global Justice of New York University School of Law that “seemingly innocuous acts (e.g. allowing refuelling at airports of aircraft of another state) can become wrongful under international law if those acts facilitate Extraordinary Rendition”…

    Colin Boyd, 13 Jan 2006: The control of flights in and out of Scotland is a reserved matter. Under international law the Chicago Convention on International Civil Aviation entitles foreign civil aircraft to make technical stops, for example for refuelling, without requiring the permission of the state in which they stop. If the police receive…
  2. S2W-22351 16 Jan 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered

    What it considers would be a “credible allegation” in respect of the ongoing allegations that US agencies have been using the process of “extraordinary rendition”, unlawfully facilitated through various Scottish airports.

    Colin Boyd, 24 Jan 2006: It is unhelpful to speculate as to information which would constitute a credible allegation. This will vary depending upon the circumstances of the alleged offence. The police will carefully consider any information provided to them and will commence an investigation if there is specific information which justifies a …
  3. S2W-22352 16 Jan 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-21768

    Whether it would consider any flight which was found to be involved in the process of “extraordinary rendition” as a civil aircraft.

    Colin Boyd, 30 Jan 2006: The question whether an aircraft is a civil aircraft will depend on the application of domestic and, so far as relevant, international law to the particular facts. The Chicago Convention of 1944 on International Civil Aviation applies only to civil and not to state aircraft, which are described as aircraft used in mil…
  4. S2W-22705 27 Jan 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-22351

    Who would find it unhelpful to speculate as to information which would constitute a credible allegation in respect of the ongoing allegations that US agencies have been using the process of “extraordinary rendition”, unlawfully facilitated through various Scottish airports.

    Colin Boyd, 7 Feb 2006: I would reiterate that speculation, meaning as it does, reasoning based on inconclusive evidence, conjecture or supposition, is not helpful. As has been stated previously in my answer to S2W-22351, no specific, credible or reliable information has, to date, been brought to the attention of the police that the “extraor…
  5. S2W-23753 2 Mar 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered

    Whether this answer indicates that the police only ever act on hard evidence and, if so, whether it can explain how crimes are investigated in the absence of hard evidence.

    Colin Boyd, 14 Mar 2006: I refer the member to the answer to question S2W-23751 on 14 March 2006. All answers to written parliamentary questions are available on the Parliament’s website, the search facility for which can be found at http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/webapp/wa.search.
  6. S2W-23832 3 Mar 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-22352

    Whether it would consider any flight which was found to be involved in the process of “extraordinary rendition” as being aircraft used for military, customs or police business on behalf of the state engaged in the process.

    Colin Boyd, 14 Mar 2006: The question as to the classification of an aircraft as either military or civilian aircraft will depend upon the application of the relevant domestic or international law to the particular facts. As I stated in my answer to question S2W-22352, “military aircraft” is defined in law. Section 92 of the Civil Aviation Ac…
  7. S2W-24678 24 Mar 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-22705

    In what way this answer indicates for whom the Executive considers it would be unhelpful if it speculated as to what would constitute a credible allegation in respect of the allegations that US agencies have used Scottish airports to facilitate the process of “extraordinary rendition”.

    Colin Boyd, 20 Apr 2006: Speculation would not be helpfulto anyone who was responsible for decisions in relation to criminal investigationsor proceedings.

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads