Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 15 questions

What information it is able to provide on any fingerprint experts working in any of the fingerprint bureaux outside of the Scottish Criminal Records Office (SCRO) who have disagreed with any of the SCRO experts fingerpr…

Started with S2W-20247 on 1 Nov 2005; latest 20 Apr 2006. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
14
longest chain 3 steps
Span
170 days
1 Nov 2005 to 20 Apr 2006
Answered
15 of 15
by Cathy Jamieson
Asked by
1
Alex Neil

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S2W-20247 1 Nov 2005 Alex Neil SNP Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive what information it is able to provide on any fingerprint experts working in any of the fingerprint bureaux outside of the Scottish Criminal Records Office (SCRO) who have disagreed with any of the SCRO experts fingerprint identifications in the last 10 years, on what the level of disagreement was and on what measures were taken to resolve these disagreements.

    Cathy Jamieson, 9 Nov 2005: The only known incidents concernthe case of Shirley McKie when staff at Aberdeen and Edinburgh subsequently formed an opinion which differed from theoriginal identification made by their colleagues in Glasgow. During the past 10 years, underthe guidance and instruction of the Lord Advocate, more than 2,000 identificat…
  2. S2W-20695 16 Nov 2005 Alex Neil SNP Answered

    What information it is able to provide on whether there have been any other incidents of disagreements involving Lothian and Borders Police fingerprint staff.

    Cathy Jamieson, 28 Nov 2005: We are not aware of any other incidents of disagreements involving Lothian and Borders Police fingerprint staff.
  3. S2W-21396 5 Dec 2005 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-20247

    When the annual competency tests and Continuous Professional Development programme were introduced for fingerprint experts.

    Cathy Jamieson, 15 Dec 2005: The annual competency tests for fingerprint officers in the Scottish Fingerprint Service began in 2002. The Continuous Professional Development programme was introduced in 2003.
  4. S2W-23155 10 Feb 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-20247

    Whether the reports by John McLeod in respect of his investigations into the Shirley McKie fingerprint case will now be made public and, if so, when they will be published; if not, what the reasons are for not publishing the reports and whether it will publish the terms of reference and the conclusions arising from these reports; whether the Executive or the Lord Advocate has commissioned any other reports into this…

    Cathy Jamieson, 20 Mar 2006: It is not my intention tomake the MacLeod reports public. They were commissioned by the Executive aspart of its defence of the civil action brought by Shirley McKie. Publicationof the MacLeod reports would undermine the basic principle of Scots law thatneither party to a litigation is obliged to disclose reports commi…
  5. S2W-23156 10 Feb 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-20247

    Whether the dispute on the identification of certain fingerprints between the Aberdeen Fingerprint Bureau and the Scottish Criminal Records Office has been resolved; if not, who has responsibility for deciding how and when it is resolved; what criteria will be used for resolving it, and what action will be taken to ensure that future fingerprint identifications will be reliable and accurate.

    Cathy Jamieson, 10 Mar 2006: The disagreement concerns identificationof a fingerprint in a criminal case which has been concluded. The answer to question S2W-23158on 17 February 2006 set out the detailed programme of work that has beenput in place since the HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary Inspection report in September2000 of the SCRO Fingerpr…
  6. S2W-23157 10 Feb 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-20247

    Whether the material which is the subject of the dispute between the Aberdeen Fingerprint Bureau and the Scottish Criminal Records Office has been peer reviewed or independently assessed at any time; if so, what the outcome was, and what the reasons are for its position on the matter.

    Cathy Jamieson, 8 Mar 2006: The fingerprint mark which was the subject of the report by three members of the Aberdeen Bureau of the Scottish Fingerprint Service has been reviewed and independently assessed by a number of people over the last nine years. Experts have reached different conclusions about the ownership of the mark.
  7. S2W-24269 15 Mar 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered

    Whether any of these reviews have been undertaken by peers inside the (a) Aberdeen, (b) Dundee, (c) Edinburgh or (d) Glasgow Fingerprint Bureau.

    Cathy Jamieson, 3 Apr 2006: It is a matter of publicrecord that some experts in the Aberdeen and Edinburgh fingerprint bureaux have taken a different view onthe identification of this print to their colleagues in the Glasgowbureau.
  8. S2W-24270 15 Mar 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-23157

    Whether it will list those individuals who have reviewed the material which is the subject of the dispute between the Aberdeen Fingerprint Bureau and the Scottish Criminal Record Office in the last nine years and what the results of these reviews were.

    Cathy Jamieson, 3 Apr 2006: As I indicated in reply toS2W-23157 answered on 8 March 2006, over the last 9 years the disputed fingerprint markhas been examined by a number of experts who have reached different conclusionson the ownership of the mark. The Scottish Executive does not hold a record ofall those experts or of their conclusions.
  9. S2W-24584 22 Mar 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-23155

    Whether John MacLeod, the author of the MacLeod reports referred to in the answer, has been asked whether he would agree to his reports being published; if so, what his response was, and, if not, whether the Executive will consider seeking his agreement to publish the reports as soon as possible.

    Cathy Jamieson, 13 Apr 2006: Mr MacLeod has indicated thatit is for the Executive to decide whether or not to waive confidentiality and topublish any report given by him. For the reasons given in my answer to questionS2W-23155 on 20 March 2006, I do not propose to publish any reports commissionedfor the purpose of the civil action brought by Shir…
  10. S2W-25243 18 Apr 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-24269

    What steps have been taken to reconcile these different views, given that the different views relate to two identifications.

    Cathy Jamieson, 1 Jun 2006: One disagreement concernsidentification of a fingerprint in a case which has been concluded and I referthe member to the question S2W-23156 answered on 10 March 2006. The other isthe subject of current civil proceedings. All answers to written parliamentaryquestions are available on the Parliament's website the search…
  11. S2W-25244 18 Apr 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-24270

    Why it does not hold such a record given that such records would have been required to defend the civil action brought by Shirley McKie that led to the settlement with her.

    Cathy Jamieson, 11 May 2006: The Scottish Executive didnot prepare such a list to defend the civil action brought by Shirley McKie.
  12. S2W-25297 20 Apr 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-23157

    Whether it will now list all the experts referred to who have reached different conclusions about the ownership of the mark and what their conclusions were.

    Cathy Jamieson, 11 May 2006: I refer the member to the answerto question S2W-24270 on 3 April 2006. All answers to written parliamentary questions areavailable on the Parliament’s website, the search facility for which can befound at http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/webapp/wa.search.
  13. S2W-25301 20 Apr 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-23155

    And in relation to the one further report commissioned by it as part of its defence of the civil action, whether it will provide details of the remit of the MacLeod reports and the one further report, when these reports were commissioned, who carried out the one further report, when the reports were completed and what the cost to it was of each report.

    Cathy Jamieson, 23 Jun 2006: Details about the reports commissionedby the Scottish Executive are given in my letter of 16 June 2006 to the Convener of the Justice 1 Committee, a copy of which is available at: http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/justice1/papers-06/j1_s2_06_24_9.pdf. The cost of each report commissionedfrom Mr Mac…
  14. S2W-25302 20 Apr 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-23155

    Whether it will provide details of when it became “a basic principle of Scots law that neither party to a litigation is obliged to disclose reports commissioned for the purpose of the litigation”; who decided to adopt this principle, and why it prevents it from voluntarily publishing these reports.

    Cathy Jamieson, 19 May 2006: The principles of Scots law,reflecting its common law tradition, have been developed and refined over time throughcase law. Relevant cases in this instance include Young v NationalCoal Board 1957 SLT 266, Johnstone v National Coal Board 1968SLT 233 and More v Brown & Root Wimpey Highland Fabricators Limited1983 SLT 66…
  15. S2W-25303 20 Apr 2006 Alex Neil SNP Answered follows S2W-23155

    Whether it will now reconsider its decision not to publish the MacLeod reports and the other report referred to, in light of the public comments made in the Scotsman newspaper on 27 March 2006 by the former Solicitor General for Scotland and High Court Judge, Lord McCluskey, that this rule “has no bearing whatsoever outside the confines of a live litigation in court”, that “there is absolutely no rule or basic princ…

    Cathy Jamieson, 17 May 2006: I refer the member to theanswers to questions S2W-23155 and S2W-25240 on 20 March 2006 and 11 May 2006 respectively.All answers to written parliamentary questions are available on the parliament’swebsite the search facility for which can be found at: www.scottish.parliament.uk/webapp/wa.search.

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads