Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 6 questions

Whether PFI or PPP projects cost more or less to the public purse over their lifetime than projects funded in the traditional manner.

Started with S2W-07791 on 26 Apr 2004; latest 3 Jun 2004. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
5
longest chain 2 steps
Span
38 days
26 Apr 2004 to 3 Jun 2004
Answered
6 of 6
by Andy Kerr
Asked by
1
Linda Fabiani

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S2W-07791 26 Apr 2004 Linda Fabiani SNP Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive whether PFI or PPP projects cost more or less to the public purse over their lifetime than projects funded in the traditional manner.

    Andy Kerr, 10 May 2004: The public privatepartnership procurement route must show value for money against a conventional procurementroute before being selected. This involves consideration of whole life costs andbenefits, for example risk transfer, for the length of the contract. So, whilstcosts may initially seem higher, approved PPP projec…
  2. S2W-08341 19 May 2004 Linda Fabiani SNP Answered

    What research and monitoring it carries out to satisfy itself that approved PPP projects are better value for money than a conventional procurement route over the lifetime of the projects concerned.

    Andy Kerr, 2 Jun 2004: Value for money is assessed atOutline business case stage and full business case stage. It is for the procuringpublic sector body to monitor value for money throughout the procurement process.
  3. S2W-08342 19 May 2004 Linda Fabiani SNP Answered follows S2W-07791

    Whether it will provide a substantive answer to the question in respect of PFI projects.

    Andy Kerr, 2 Jun 2004: Guidance on the considerationof the public private partnership procurement route compared to the conventionalprocurement route is set out in Treasury Taskforce Technical Note No. 5 How toConstruct a Public Sector Comparator, a copy of which has been placed in the Parliament’s Reference Centre (Bib. number 20725).
  4. S2W-08739 3 Jun 2004 Linda Fabiani SNP Answered follows S2W-08341

    How it monitors value for money in those projects for which it is the procuring body.

    Andy Kerr, 16 Jun 2004: The monitoring of value for money applies to all publicly procured projects, and the Treasury’s Green Book provides guidance on appraisal and evaluation of projects for Government. Guidance specifically on the value for money of public private partnership projects is contained in Treasury Taskforce publications which …
  5. S2W-08740 3 Jun 2004 Linda Fabiani SNP Answered follows S2W-08341

    What research and monitoring it carries out to ensure that procuring bodies have the necessary expertise to monitor properly value for money issues in approved PPP projects.

    Andy Kerr, 17 Jun 2004: It is for public sector procuring bodies to ensure that they have the necessary expertise to undertake a public private partnership project, including the monitoring of value for money issues. As PPP projects usually involve large investments over a long period, and the procurement process can be complex, it is recomm…
  6. S2W-08741 3 Jun 2004 Linda Fabiani SNP Answered follows S2W-08341

    What research it is undertaking, or has commissioned, into value for money issues surrounding the general principles of PFI and PPP.

    Andy Kerr, 16 Jun 2004: The Executive has been involved in dialogue with Treasury over the new Green Book, and over an improved approach to the appraisal of public private partnerships. Treasury issued Draft Value for Money Appraisal Guidance in February which sets out new proposals for a value for money assessment, including the reform of t…

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads