Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 14 questions

Why the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body is unable to comply with its obligations regarding the payment of employer pension contributions to the personal pensions of MSPs' staff, as required by changes to Occupatio…

Started with S2W-01566 on 16 Jul 2003; latest 12 Jul 2004. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
13
longest chain 2 steps
Span
362 days
16 Jul 2003 to 12 Jul 2004
Answered
14 of 14
by Duncan McNeil
Asked by
2
MSPs

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S2W-01566 16 Jul 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered

    To ask the Presiding Officer why the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body is unable to comply with its obligations regarding the payment of employer pension contributions to the personal pensions of MSPs' staff, as required by changes to Occupational Pensions Regulatory Authority regulations in April 2001, if it uses the direct debit scheme.

    Duncan McNeil, 6 Aug 2003: Under theOccupational Pensions Regulatory Authority an employer has obligations to maintain a record of payments made, send a record ofpayments made to the pension provider and pay the correct amount ofcontribution over by the 19th of the month following the pay run in which thecontributions are collected. Under the d…
  2. S2W-01861 7 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered also cites S2W-1567, S2W-1568, S2W-1569

    Whether the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB) has any plans to compensate any staff whose personal pension payments and arrangements have been adversely affected by the decision to withdraw from the direct debit scheme and what the reasons are for its position on this matter.

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Aug 2003: The SPCB has noplans to compensate any staff whose personal pension payments and arrangementshave been adversely affected by the decision to change the method of paymentand withdraw from the direct debit scheme. The SPCB has complied with itsobligations under the Occupational Pensions Regulatory Authority and ensuredt…
  3. S2W-01862 7 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01566 also cites S2W-1567, S2W-1568, S2W-1569

    Whether the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB) has any plans to apologise formally to any staff, whose personal pension payments and arrangements have been adversely affected by the decision to withdraw from the direct debit scheme, in respect of the decision on this matter and any lack of consultation

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Aug 2003: The SPCB empathiseswith staff who have encountered problems. However, since it has complied withits obligations under Occupational PensionsRegulatory Authority and it has no influence on when the pensionproviders apply the contributions to the pension policies, the SPCB has noplans to apologise formally for the withdr…
  4. S2W-01863 7 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01566 also cites S2W-1567, S2W-1568, S2W-1569

    Which pension providers (a) responded and (b) did not respond to the correspondence sent to them relating to the ending of the direct debit scheme.

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Aug 2003: The table below lists thepension providers who responded to our correspondence within three months ofreceipt and those who did not. Did respond within the first three months | Did not respond within the first three months Abbey Life Abbey National Allied Dunbar CIS Friends Provident Guardian Royal Exchange Perpetual I…
  5. S2W-01864 7 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01566 also cites S2W-1567, S2W-1568, S2W-1569

    What the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB) considers its responsibility to be in relation to the communication of matters, and decisions that it takes, directly affecting staff employed by MSPs and what methods of communication are in place to ensure that such staff are appropriately informed of, and consulted on, such matters and decisions.

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Aug 2003: The SPCB hasvarious ways of keeping staff employed by MSPs informed of issues that maydirectly affect them, for example: through the use of e-mail; notices;telephone; letters etc. In this case, however, because these procedural changeswere made in order to comply with legislation, it was not considered necessaryto con…
  6. S2W-01865 7 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01566 also cites S2W-1567, S2W-1568, S2W-1569

    What steps the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB) is taking to address the issues relating to its inability to meet its obligations in relation to compliance with Occupational Pensions Regulatory Authority (OPRA) regulations in order that the reintroduction of the direct debit scheme can be considered.

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Aug 2003: The only way that the SPCB canensure that it complies fully with the regulations of OPRA is for it to havecomplete control over the payments made to the pension providers. Since thedirect debit system gives the pension provider full control of when and howmuch is collected, the SPCB will not be re-introducing the dire…
  7. S2W-01866 7 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01566 also cites S2W-1567, S2W-1568, S2W-1569

    How many staff have been affected by the decision of the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB) to withdraw from the direct debit scheme.

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Aug 2003: Following the decision to withdrawfrom the direct debit scheme there are problems currently outstanding whichaffect eight members of staff all with the one provider. However, the SPCB has nowagreed a way forward with the provider to resolve these.
  8. S2W-01867 7 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01566 also cites S2W-1567, S2W-1568, S2W-1569

    What steps the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB) took to inform MSPs, as employers, of the impact its decision to withdraw from the direct debit scheme would have on their staffs' pension payments.

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Aug 2003: As none of the providershighlighted any specific problems prior to the withdrawal of the direct debitscheme and no problems were envisaged, the SPCB felt that it was notnecessary to inform individual MSPs of the change in the method of payment.
  9. S2W-02289 29 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01865

    How many external organisations the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body has made payments to under the direct debit scheme

    Duncan McNeil, 23 Sep 2003: The total number of externalorganisations that the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body has made paymentsto under the direct debit scheme is 24.
  10. S2W-02290 29 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01864

    On how many occasions the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body has communicated specifically with MSPs' staff on matters directly affecting them.

    Duncan McNeil, 23 Sep 2003: The Scottish ParliamentaryCorporate Body is unable to quantify on how many occasions it has communicatedspecifically with MSPs’ staff on matters directly affecting them.
  11. S2W-02291 29 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01861

    What steps the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body has taken to establish whether any MSPs' staff affected by the change in the payment system for personal pensions have incurred loss as a result.

    Duncan McNeil, 23 Sep 2003: As the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body has complied with its obligations under theOccupational Pensions Regulatory Authority rules to pay over pension contributionsby the 19th day of each month, it has not deemed it necessary to take steps toestablish whether any MSPs’ staff affected by the change in the payment…
  12. S2W-02293 29 Aug 2003 Donald Gorrie LD Answered follows S2W-01866

    How many staff were initially affected by the change in direct debit payments in respect of their personal pensions.

    Duncan McNeil, 23 Sep 2003: The number of MSPs staff whowere initially affected by the change was 151.
  13. S2W-09688 12 Jul 2004 Fergus Ewing SNP Answered follows S2W-01861

    Whether any MSPs' staff have been adversely affected by the decision to cease making pension payments by direct debit and, if so, whether any details of any such cases were reported to the SPCB.

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Jul 2004: In total to date there havebeen 10 members’ staff (9 with plans with one provider and 1 with a plan withanother provider) affected by the decision to cease making pensioncontributions from the Parliament’s bank account by direct debit. The SPCB hasbeen kept informed of this issue, including the efforts made to resolve…
  14. S2W-09691 12 Jul 2004 Fergus Ewing SNP Answered follows S2W-01861

    Why “experience has shown” that the SPCB could not guarantee to make payments by the 19th of the month following the pay run in which the contributions are collected and what that experience has been; why the SPCB is unable to make an arrangement which complies with this time deadline using direct debit, and when the SPCB will provide a full explanation of this matter to MSPs.

    Duncan McNeil, 28 Jul 2004: Previously,contributions were paid by a combination of BACS, cheques and direct debits. Inthe case of the direct debit facility, it gave pension providers authority tocollect contributions direct from an SPCB bank account. However, experienceshowed that: if anindividual’s pension contribution increased by a small amou…

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads