Question thread · 10 questions
What processes are used to select senior judges, sheriff principals and sheriff substitutes; who makes the final decision on recommending such appointments; who makes the final appointments, and whether it has any plans…
Started with S2W-00972 on 19 Jun 2003; latest 1 Sep 2003. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.
The thread, in order
Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text-
To ask the Scottish Executive what processes are used to select senior judges, sheriff principals and sheriff substitutes; who makes the final decision on recommending such appointments; who makes the final appointments, and whether it has any plans to alter the present selection and appointment system.
Cathy Jamieson, 30 Jun 2003: Since May 2002 it has been for the independent Judicial Appointments Board to make recommendations to the First Minister for the appointment of judges, sheriffs principal and sheriffs. Under section 95 of the Scotland 1998, it is then for the First Minister to make the final recommendations to the Queen. The sole exce… -
How many nominations the First Minister makes to the Prime Minister to fill the vacant office of (a) Lord President of the Court of Session and (b) Lord Justice Clerk.
Hugh Henry, 1 Aug 2003: There is no statutory requirement but it is normal practice for the First Minister to offer the Prime Minister a choice of names to fill vacancies for the office of Lord President and Lord Justice Clerk. When appointments were being considered in 2001 the Prime Minister accepted the First Minister's recommended choice… -
What the process would be if the Prime Minister did not accept one of the First Minister's nominations to fill the vacant office of (a) Lord President of the Court of Session and (b) Lord Justice Clerk.
Hugh Henry, 29 Jul 2003: The Statute envisages that the First Minister and Prime Minister will come to an agreement on these matters and there is no precedent for their not doing so. -
Whether it intends to establish the Judicial Appointments Board on a statutory basis.
Hugh Henry, 29 Jul 2003: Ministers have made clear since the inception of the board that it was their intention to place it on a statutory footing after a period of experience of working administratively. That remains the Executive's policy. -
For what period members of the Judicial Appointment Board are appointed.
Hugh Henry, 29 Jul 2003: All members of the board, including the chair, were appointed for three years in the first instance. -
What interests members of the Judicial Appointments Board are required to declare and whether any such declaration of interests is available for public examination.
Hugh Henry, 29 Jul 2003: Members are required to declare any conflict of interest which may affect prejudicially their performance as members of the board. They are also asked to declare any political activity. Members have confirmed that they see no conflicts of interest and that none is involved in political activity. During the selection p… -
By what process members of the Judicial Appointments Board are appointed and who appoints them.
Hugh Henry, 29 Jul 2003: The lay members of the board were appointed after public advertisement and interview. Three of the five legal members were also interviewed. The High Court judge was nominated by the Lord President. The Sheriff Principal was nominated by the convener of the Sheriffs principal group. In all cases the First Minister mad… -
Who conducted the interviews for membership of the Judicial Appointments Board and how the interview panel was selected.
Cathy Jamieson, 9 Sep 2003: The process was carried outin accordance with the Code of Practice of the Commissioner for PublicAppointments. Interviews were conducted by the Rt Hon Lord Ross (the formerLord Justice Clerk), Mr Alastair Dempster (former Chief Executive of TSBScotland and a member of the Panel of Independent Assessors) and Mr J DGall… -
Whether incumbent members of the Judicial Appointments Board will be involved in future interviews for membership of the board.
Cathy Jamieson, 9 Sep 2003: The current members of theJudicial Appointments Board have all been appointed until mid-2005. Decisionson replacing them will not be taken until late in 2004. I have no plans toinvite board members to play a part in choosing their successors. -
How many nominations were made by the (a) Lord President for a High Court judge and (b) Convener of the Sheriffs principal group for the Sheriff Principal to sit on the Judicial Appointment Boards.
Cathy Jamieson, 9 Sep 2003: The Lord President nominatedone judge from the group of 10 Inner House Judges. The convener of the SheriffsPrincipal nominated one Sheriff Principal from the group of six.
How this thread is put together
- Follow-up
- A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
- Several citations
- When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
- Thread
- Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.