Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 8 questions

What work has been carried out by its officials on the clauses applying to Scotland in the draft Extradition Bill relating to the European arrest warrant.

Started with S1W-30691 on 16 Oct 2002; latest 10 Dec 2002. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
7
longest chain 1 step
Span
55 days
16 Oct 2002 to 10 Dec 2002
Answered
8 of 8
by Hugh Henry, Jim Wallace, Richard Simpson
Asked by
3
MSPs

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S1W-30691 16 Oct 2002 Roseanna Cunningham SNP Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive what work has been carried out by its officials on the clauses applying to Scotland in the draft Extradition Bill relating to the European arrest warrant.

    Richard Simpson, 8 Nov 2002: My officials have been preparing appropriate amendments to the bill as a whole to ensure that the new legislative framework for extradition as proposed in the bill will operate satisfactorily in Scotland. This work covers those clauses which implement the Framework Decision on the European Arrest Warrant.
  2. S1W-31987 26 Nov 2002 Roseanna Cunningham SNP Answered

    What the cost was of work done by its officials on clauses of, and amendments to, the Extradition Bill and who bore the costs.

    Jim Wallace, 10 Dec 2002: An estimate of the cost of the work could only be provided at disproportionate cost. The expenditure involved was borne by the Scottish Executive.
  3. S1W-32292 5 Dec 2002 Fiona Hyslop SNP Answered follows S1W-30691

    Whether it drafted any amendment to the Extradition Bill relating to postponing bringing into force the sections of the bill relating to implementation of the European arrest warrant until the European Commission's review of minimum procedural safeguards for suspects and accused was completed and what the reasons are for its position on this matter.

    Hugh Henry, 16 Dec 2002: The question of postponing the bringing into force those parts of the Extradition Bill implementing the European arrest warrant pending the outcome of the European Council's review of minimum procedural standards is a policy issue for the UK Government given that the bill relates to a reserved matter.
  4. S1W-32397 6 Dec 2002 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S1W-30691

    What steps it has taken, in drafting amendments to the Extradition Bill, to ensure protections equivalent to the 110-day rule or the English writ of habeas corpus in trials of persons arrested using the European arrest warrant procedure.

    Hugh Henry, 16 Dec 2002: None. I would refer the member to the provisions of the Council of the European Union Framework Decision on the European arrest warrant (EAW) about time limits and procedures for the execution of the EAW which are being implemented by means of the Extradition Bill. These provide for a timescale of a maximum 70 days, o…
  5. S1W-32398 6 Dec 2002 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S1W-30691

    Whether, in drafting amendments to the Extradition Bill, it sought to postpone bringing into force the clauses of the bill relating to implementation of the European arrest warrant until common standards with regard to the presumption of innocence have been adopted across the European Union and common standards with regard to the (a) right to legal advice and representation, (b) rules of evidence and (c) practice of…

    Hugh Henry, 16 Dec 2002: The question of postponing the bringing into force of any part of the Extradition Bill for any reason is a policy issue for the UK Government given that the bill relates to a reserved matter.
  6. S1W-32399 6 Dec 2002 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S1W-30691

    Whether, in drafting amendments to the Extradition Bill, its officials played a role in drafting clauses 7(6), 76(2), 83(7) and 85(7) and, if so, what specific work they carried out on these clauses.

    Hugh Henry, 16 Dec 2002: Executive officials considered the provisions in clauses 7, 76, 83 and 85 for England and Wales and, given that the bill provides for a legislative framework which should, so far as is possible, provide consistent law throughout the UK, instructed provisions that were comparable for Scotland.
  7. S1W-32400 6 Dec 2002 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S1W-30691

    What legal advice it received, in preparing amendments to the Extradition Bill, with regard to the removal of the requirement in Scots law of corroboration of the identity of the accused for the implementation of the European arrest warrant.

    Jim Wallace, 20 Jan 2003: Legal advice was obtained as appropriate to ensure that the bill made it clear that, in line with the rest of the United Kingdom, corroboration was not required in Scotland.
  8. S1W-32503 10 Dec 2002 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S1W-30691

    What consideration it has given, in drafting amendments to the Extradition Bill in respect of the European arrest warrant, to the decision of the English High Court of Justice in R ex parte Ramda v Secretary of State for the Home Department (27 June 2002) in which the court stated that since the European Court of Human Rights is not a court of appeal and there is no recourse to it as of right, the Home Secretary was…

    Hugh Henry, 23 Dec 2002: Clause 21 of the bill makes it clear that before the sheriff can make a decision ordering the person's extradition, he must be satisfied that the extradition would be compatible the person's Convention rights, including the article 6 right to a fair trial.

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads