Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 8 questions

Whether it will make representations to Her Majesty's Government as to why information regarding litigation by the Ministry of Defence against manufacturers of the Chinook FADEC system was apparently not made available …

Started with S1W-02120 on 25 Oct 1999; latest 10 Jan 2000. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
7
longest chain 3 steps
Span
77 days
25 Oct 1999 to 10 Jan 2000
Answered
8 of 8
by Andrew Hardie
Asked by
1
Kenny MacAskill

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S1W-02120 25 Oct 1999 Kenny MacAskill SNP Answered

    To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will make representations to Her Majesty's Government as to why information regarding litigation by the Ministry of Defence against manufacturers of the Chinook FADEC system was apparently not made available to the fatal accident inquiry in 1996 into the crash of ZD576 RAF Chinook on the Mull of Kintyre, and whether it can confirm that it has now received all documentation re…

    Andrew Hardie, 10 Nov 1999: When allegations about the FADEC system were first made the Crown Office immediately sought and thereafter obtained a very full account of the issue from the Ministry of Defence. The litigation, which was settled out of court, related to the test of a pre-production version of the software in conditions of simulated b…
  2. S1W-02585 16 Nov 1999 Kenny MacAskill SNP Answered

    By Lord Hardie, when the Crown Office obtained a full account of the litigation by the Ministry of Defence against the manufacturers of the Chinook FADEC system.

    Andrew Hardie, 26 Nov 1999: This matter came to the attention of the Crown Office on 30 December 1997. That same day a letter was sent to the Ministry of Defence asking for full information. That information was received on 17 March 1998.
  3. S1W-02586 16 Nov 1999 Kenny MacAskill SNP Answered follows S1W-02120

    By Lord Hardie, whether the information concerning the litigation by the Ministry of Defence against the manufacturers of the Chinook FADEC system was made available to the legal agents for the families of the victims of the crash of ZD576 RAF Chinook on the Mull of Kintyre and, if so, when.

    Andrew Hardie, 26 Nov 1999: Yes. The information was received by Crown Office on 17 March 1998, considered carefully against the evidence led at the Fatal Accident Inquiry and the Determination and then passed on to the solicitors by letter dated 23 April 1998.
  4. S1W-02587 16 Nov 1999 Kenny MacAskill SNP Answered follows S1W-02120

    By Lord Hardie, what the nature was of the settlement between the Ministry of Defence and the manufacturers of the Chinook FADEC system and whether there was an implied or explicit admission of liability in relation to the system.

    Andrew Hardie, 26 Nov 1999: The details and basis of the settlement in question are a matter for the Ministry of Defence.
  5. S1W-02912 2 Dec 1999 Kenny MacAskill SNP Answered follows S1W-02120

    Whether the allegations referred to were made in the media coverage regarding the FADEC system and whether any information was provided by the Ministry of Defence regarding the FADEC litigation prior to the Crown Office seeking information.

    Andrew Hardie, 14 Dec 1999: Questions about the FADEC software were first brought to the attention of the Crown Office by solicitors acting for the family of one of those killed in the accident.
  6. S1W-03010 7 Dec 1999 Kenny MacAskill SNP Answered follows S1W-02585

    Whether it will give details of what enquiries or representations it has made or proposes to make and what has prompted it to make such enquires or representations, as to why the information relating to the litigation in the United States by the Ministry of Defence (MoD) against the manufacturers of the Chinook FADEC system, which was concluded in or about November 1995, was not made available to the Crown Office un…

    Andrew Hardie, 21 Dec 1999: When allegations about the FADEC system were first made the Crown Office immediately sought and thereafter obtained a very full account of the issue from the Ministry of Defence. The litigation, which was settled out of court, related to the test of a pre-production version of the software in conditions of simulated b…
  7. S1W-03471 21 Dec 1999 Kenny MacAskill SNP Answered follows S1W-02120

    When and by whom information regarding litigation by the Ministry of Defence against the manufacturers of the FADEC system was brought to the attention of the Crown Office.

    Andrew Hardie, 19 Jan 2000: As I explained in my answer to question S1W-2912, questions about the FADEC software were first brought to the attention of the Crown Office by solicitors acting for the family of one of those killed in the accident. As I explained in my answer to question S1W-2585, that was on 30 December 1997. As I explained in my a…
  8. S1W-03610 10 Jan 2000 Kenny MacAskill SNP Answered follows S1W-03010

    Whether the Crown Office was advised by the Ministry of Defence as to whether all of the software defects in the Chinook FADEC system were removed by the time the FADEC system went into production.

    Andrew Hardie, 24 Jan 2000: The information which Crown Office obtained from the Ministry of Defence focussed on whether there were any defects in the FADEC system which could conceivably have contributed to the crash. The Ministry of Defence explained that there were no such defects. As I explained in my answer to question S1W-2002, and repeate…

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads