Question thread · 6 questions
What is the cost of answering the thirty-eight questions tabled by Keith Raffan MSP as published in the Scottish Parliament Business Bulletin of Friday 9 July 1999.
Started with S1W-00521 on 12 Jul 1999; latest 6 Jul 2000. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.
The thread, in order
Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text-
To ask the Scottish Executive what is the cost of answering the thirty-eight questions tabled by Keith Raffan MSP as published in the Scottish Parliament Business Bulletin of Friday 9 July 1999.
Jack McConnell, 23 Aug 1999: Preliminary work on estimating the cost of answering Scottish Parliamentary Questions suggests an average cost of about £100 per question - a figure that is consistent with evidence from the UK Parliament. This takes account of time spent by staff of the Scottish Executive on dealing with questions and a proportion of… -
Further to the answer to question S1W-521 by Mr Jack McConnell on 23 August, how the #100 average cost of answering a Scottish Parliamentary Question was calculated and whether this average cost is a mode, median or mean average.
Jack McConnell, 17 Sep 1999: The £100 average cost was calculated by estimating the amount of time spent by members of staff of the Scottish Executive on dealing with a limited sample of Scottish Parliamentary Questions covering a range of subjects. Staff time was costed to include, for each grade of staff, a share of the overhead costs of the Sc… -
Further to the answer to question S1W-521 by Mr Jack McConnell on 23 August, whether the reference to the #100 average cost of answering a Scottish Parliamentary Question being consistent with evidence from the UK Parliament means that the cost of answering Scottish Parliamentary Questions is (a) the same as or (b) different from the cost of answering UK Parliamentary Questions and, if it is different, whether the c…
Jack McConnell, 17 Sep 1999: The average cost of £100 for answering written Scottish Parliamentary Questions is an estimate based on preliminary work undertaken over a short period and using a relatively small sample of questions. The Executive intends to undertake a detailed study of the cost of answering questions over the coming months and wil… -
Whether it will publish the detailed computation referred to in those answers showing how the conclusion that the average cost of answering written Scottish Parliamentary Questions is #100 was arrived at.
Jack McConnell, 7 Dec 1999: The estimated average cost of answering Scottish Parliamentary Questions which was provided in previous answers was calculated by asking Departments of the Scottish Executive to take a sample of such questions and to make an assessment of the time spent at each grade on preparing an answer. The standard costs for each… -
When it expects to have available a more comprehensive assessment of the costs of answering parliamentary questions and whether this will include a detailed breakdown of the #100 average cost of answering a parliamentary question.
Jack McConnell, 1 Mar 2000: We are finalising the arrangements for a major study to assess the amount of time Scottish Executive staff spend on dealing with parliamentary questions. This exercise will involve tracking up to 500 written and 200 oral questions. The data gathered from this exercise will be used to calculate the average costs of ans… -
When it expects to make available to the Parliament a report on the cost of answering parliamentary questions.
Jack McConnell, 6 Jul 2000: The main part of the study into the costs of answering parliamentary questions has now been completed. However, the data collected over the survey period is still being analysed and it will not be possible to complete the study before the summer recess. Rather than publish the report during recess, we now plan to make…
How this thread is put together
- Follow-up
- A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
- Several citations
- When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
- Thread
- Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.