Written Question · S7W-04317 · Session 7
What action is being taken in response to paragraph 1.105 of the COVID-19 Inquiry Module 3 report, which states that "all hospitals built i…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government what action is being taken in response to paragraph 1.105 of the COVID-19 Inquiry Module 3 report, which states that "all hospitals built in England in the context of the UK government’s New Hospital Programme – and any new facilities built in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland – ought to be designed in a way that maximises the opportunities for effective ventilation" and that "In the short term, the use of HEPA filters should be prioritised within healthcare across the UK."
The answer
On 17 September 2026, the Scottish Government responded to the recommendations of the UK Covid-19 Inquiry Module 3 Report, committing to strengthen pandemic preparedness and healthcare system resilience.The published response to Recommendation 5 and 6 states:"Health Boards are also undertaking a review of current plans for expanding hospital and critical care capacity. The Scottish Government has asked that this includes:• Additional bed capacity• Critical care expansion capability• Availability of equipment, supplies and consumables• Workforce• Infrastructure requirements• Command, control and decision-making arrangementsReturns from this exercise are expected by the end of September 2026 and will give the Scottish Government an overview of current arrangements, key risks, what actions Boards are planning to address, any gaps and what the resource and funding implications are. It will also offer government assurance that adequately robust arrangements are in place. The national review of the Board returns and identification of common themes is due for completion by December 2026.Where areas for improvement are identified, Health Boards will develop and implement actions to strengthen preparedness and resilience. From 2027, ongoing review and testing of the plans through resilience exercises will commence, with a formal review of plans being undertaken every three years thereafter, whilst also being updated regularly to ensure they remain effective and fit for purpose and in line with equalities considerations. The expectation is that this initial review and improvement work will be concluded by March 2027.Recommendations 5 and 6 will be added to the agenda of a standing four nations meeting to ensure alignment and a co-ordinated approach across the four nations. Scottish Government will then monitor these on an ongoing basis so that ministers and the public can be assured that the lessons identified by the Inquiry are being addressed."The Director General for Health and Social Care, working with the Directorate for the Chief Operating Officer, NHS Scotland within the Scottish Government, will be accountable for the implementation of the Scottish elements of this recommendation.NHS Scotland Boards manage healthcare ventilation systems in accordance with SHTM 03-01: Ventilation for Healthcare Premises and the principles of SHTM 00: Best Practice Guidance for Healthcare Engineering. SHTM 03-01 Part A sets out requirements for the design, installation, commissioning and validation of ventilation systems for new build and refurbishment projects, whilst Part B covers the operational management, maintenance, inspection, testing and performance verification of existing systems.In line with SHTM 03-01 Part B, Boards should maintain appropriate arrangements to ensure that existing ventilation systems continue to operate effectively and provide the required environmental conditions. Ventilation performance should be assessed using a risk based approach. While SHTM guidance does not mandate carbon dioxide (CO2) monitoring, Boards may use CO2 monitoring where appropriate to support ventilation performance assessment, occupancy management and local risk assessment.Where ventilation standards cannot readily be achieved, particularly within older or constrained healthcare estates, Boards should undertake multidisciplinary risk assessments involving estates and engineering teams, IPC specialists, clinicians and other relevant stakeholders. Where improvements to fixed ventilation systems are not reasonably practicable, HEPA filtration may be deployed as part of a package of risk mitigations, alongside enhanced IPC precautions, patient cohorting, occupancy management and other operational controls, as appropriate.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S7W-04317 by reference.