Written Question · S7W-03869 · Session 7
What mechanisms exist to prevent an NHS manager who has been found responsible for serious misconduct or patient safety failings from movin…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government what mechanisms exist to prevent an NHS manager who has been found responsible for serious misconduct or patient safety failings from moving into a management role in another NHS board, and whether it will review these arrangements in light of Recommendation 13 of the Thirlwall Inquiry.
The answer
National guidance for NHS employers on safe recruitment practices has been in place since 2007. This has been frequently updated, culminating in the extant NHSScotland Employment Checks Policy and supporting documents being published in August 2025. This policy ensures a consistent approach by setting the standard for employment practice that all our boards follow. It applies to all candidates for employment and employees as well as current and future bank staff, agency staff, sessional workers, volunteers, contractors, secondees and those on placement or work experience, including trainees and students.In addition to recommendations for stronger safeguards when senior managers transfer between NHS employers in England, Lady Justice Thirwell also recommended that the Department of Health and Social Care and NHS England establishes a statutory manager barring system by September 2027. The UK Government confirmed in July 2025 its intention to proceed with legislation to create such a mechanism for NHS senior managers in England, operated by the Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC). As the HCPC is a UK-wide regulator, accountable to the Scottish Parliament for groups regulated after devolution, the territorial extent of that legislation may be extended to Scotland at the request of the Scottish Ministers. That work is at an early stage and we will determine the potential suitability of proposals for our devolved services at the earliest opportunity.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S7W-03869 by reference.