Written Question · S7W-01727 · Session 7
How many children are currently placed in each of Scotland's four secure accommodation centres on welfare grounds only, and in how many cas…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government how many children are currently placed in each of Scotland's four secure accommodation centres on welfare grounds only, and in how many cases such children are accommodated within the same living unit as children detained under criminal justice legislation.
The answer
The population in secure care can change at least daily, due in part to the short-term nature of some placements, and in part due to an active approach towards minimising the time that children spend under a care regime that requires the deprivation of liberty. Real time data on the make-up of the population in secure that identifies the reasons for which they have been placed there is not held centrally.All of Scotland’s secure accommodation services offer an integrated model of delivery, usually caring for children together regardless of the route via which they have been placed in secure accommodation. This is consistent with Scotland’s approach to The Promise, GIRFEC and the Kilbrandon ethos
- namely that both children who have been offended against and children who have committed offences are all to be seen, understood, and responded to, as children in need. The Kilbrandon report states “in terms of the child's actual needs, the legal distinction between juvenile offenders and children in need of care or protection was-looking to the underlying realities-very often of little practical significance”. These matters were directly considered by Parliament during scrutiny of the Bills that became the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Act 2024 and the Children (Care, Care Experience and Services Planning (Scotland) Act 2026.
- namely that both children who have been offended against and children who have committed offences are all to be seen, understood, and responded to, as children in need. The Kilbrandon report states “in terms of the child's actual needs, the legal distinction between juvenile offenders and children in need of care or protection was-looking to the underlying realities-very often of little practical significance”. These matters were directly considered by Parliament during scrutiny of the Bills that became the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Act 2024 and the Children (Care, Care Experience and Services Planning (Scotland) Act 2026.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S7W-01727 by reference.