Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S6W-37932 · Session 6

What assessment it undertook that resulted in it determining that CalMac should be directly awarded the Clyde and Hebrides Ferry Services c…

Answered Asked by Ash Regan Alba Lodged 21 May 2025

The question

To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it undertook that resulted in it determining that CalMac should be directly awarded the Clyde and Hebrides Ferry Services contract without an open tender process, in light of it stating that directly awarding the contract for the Small Vessel Replacement Programme to Ferguson Marine would present a legal risk.

The answer

Answered by Fiona Hyslop on 5 Jun 2025 · 15 days after it was lodged, on time

Direct award of public contracts is only possible in strictly limited circumstances under public procurement rules.The CHFS3 decision was subject to a due diligence process which concluded there was no financial, operational or legal impediment to implementing a Teckal-compliant direct award.Shipbuilding is a competitive global market and a designated sensitive sector under the UK Subsidy Control Act. For SVRP, it was assessed that a substantial subsidy would have been required to support direct award of the Phase 1 contract to Fergusons, which we did not consider would be capable of being justified. Given no clear path to subsidy control compliance and the risks of legal challenge, Ministers concluded that directly awarding the Phase 1 contract would have been likely to lead to the worst of both worlds
- a delay in adding new ferries to the network and the yard ultimately not securing any work from the programme.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S6W-37932 by reference.