Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S6W-01931 · Session 6

On what date ministers were first made aware that the OECD was not accepting written submissions to its review of the Curriculum for Excell…

Answered Asked by Oliver Mundell Con Lodged 27 Jul 2021

The question

To ask the Scottish Government on what date ministers were first made aware that the OECD was not accepting written submissions to its review of the Curriculum for Excellence.

The answer

Answered by Shirley-Anne Somerville on 9 Aug 2021 · 13 days after it was lodged, on time

The OECD did not take formal written submissions for their independent Review of Curriculum for Excellence. This was the OECD’s position from the outset of the review and conforms with their ‘Implementing Policies: Supporting Change in Education Framework’. This was outlined in the Scottish Government’s answers to S5W-35079 on 18 February 2021 and S5W-35292 on 25 February 2021 and made clear in the remit for the OECD’s review which was published on 26 February 2020.
The OECD uses this framework to provide tailored support to individual countries and education systems to analyse and support the development and implementation of education policies. This methodology has been used by the OECD in previous reviews, and set a very clear framework for their work in Scotland.
The OECD were clear that it was not feasible for them to consider more information than they specifically requested, nor was the purpose of the Review to generate new written submissions or replace what would otherwise be a national consultation. They advised that should any additional information be required at a later date, they would request this.
In terms of the OECD’s approach to evidence gathering on this Review, the OECD established a team of core OECD staff and international experts with experience in curriculum and assessment implementation. The process included:A comprehensive desk-based analysis of policy documents, evidence and research on CfE implementation, which included, amongst other documents, the initial evidence base provided by the Scottish Government in July 2020, papers published as part of the Education & Skills Committee’s Inquiry on Subject Choice and published academic articles and research.Compilation of information from key stakeholders’ websites and think tank publications.A series of interviews and virtual school visits plus focus groups to gather primary data. These included discussions with the Scottish Parliament’s Education and Skills Committee, Scottish Government officials, national agencies, local government representatives, college and university bodies, employer groups, academics, teachers and head teachers, parents, young people, Gaelic and subject specific interest groups, and members of Scotland’s education governance groups.
This represented a significant and comprehensive amount of documentation, with many different perspectives informing the review.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S6W-01931 by reference.