Written Question · S5W-26407 · Session 5
Whether it remains committed to using the mutual investment model (MIM) for funding infrastructure projects and, if so, what its response i…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government whether it remains committed to using the mutual investment model (MIM) for funding infrastructure projects and, if so, what its response is to the comment by the Finance Committee of the National Assembly for Wales in its report, Inquiry into the Welsh Government’s capital funding sources, that "it is hard to establish a significant difference between the two models [MIM and PFI], specifically as to how MIM offers greater value for money than previous PFI models".
The answer
The Scottish Government has committed to a significant, ongoing boost in annual investment in vital infrastructure in the National Infrastructure Mission. This enables Scotland to reach the level of international competitors.
The Mission will be funded and financed from a combination of approaches. Alongside capital grant and capital borrowing, a range of tools and approaches will be deployed, including our potential to utilise a Scottish version of the Welsh Mutual Investment Model (MIM) as recommended by the Scottish Futures Trust.
The constraints and tight limits on Scottish Government capital borrowing under the Fiscal Framework make revenue finance a necessity to build the infrastructure we need. Were broader borrowing powers available to the Scottish Government, we could re-visit consideration of the best tools and approaches to deploy.
The Welsh Finance Committee acknowledged benefits of the Mutual Investment Model, noting, “MIM is an improvement in terms of community benefits and oversight of projects”. The Welsh Finance Committee report also noted, “The majority of evidence from witnesses agreed that MIM is an improvement on the previous PFI models utilised in the UK”.
The Mission will be funded and financed from a combination of approaches. Alongside capital grant and capital borrowing, a range of tools and approaches will be deployed, including our potential to utilise a Scottish version of the Welsh Mutual Investment Model (MIM) as recommended by the Scottish Futures Trust.
The constraints and tight limits on Scottish Government capital borrowing under the Fiscal Framework make revenue finance a necessity to build the infrastructure we need. Were broader borrowing powers available to the Scottish Government, we could re-visit consideration of the best tools and approaches to deploy.
The Welsh Finance Committee acknowledged benefits of the Mutual Investment Model, noting, “MIM is an improvement in terms of community benefits and oversight of projects”. The Welsh Finance Committee report also noted, “The majority of evidence from witnesses agreed that MIM is an improvement on the previous PFI models utilised in the UK”.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S5W-26407 by reference.