Written Question · S5W-21891 · Session 5
For what reason the Human Tissue (Authorisation) (Scotland) Bill stipulates that a family member or close friend must present "evidence tha…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government for what reason the Human Tissue (Authorisation) (Scotland) Bill stipulates that a family member or close friend must present "evidence that would convince a reasonable person", and what consideration it has given to using the wording provided in the Human Transplantation (Wales) Act 2013, which states that the third party need only provide "knowledge" of the deceased’s wishes that would convince a reasonable person.
The answer
The Human Tissue (Authorisation) (Scotland) Bill includes safeguards which aim to ensure that evidence of a potential donor’s views about donation can be provided in order to ascertain whether or not donation is authorised.
The provisions, including the Duty to Inquire provisions, are designed to provide a clear mechanism for inquiries to be made of the relevant people and for those people to be able to bring evidence forward, if necessary. The Bill does not require the evidence to be in any particular form and the provisions are designed to be flexible to allow the Specialist Nurses for Organ Donation (SNODs) and Tissue Donor Co-ordinators to take into account different types of evidence provided and to reach a conclusion as to whether the evidence represents the potential donor’s views.
In developing the Bill, the approach taken in the Human Transplantation (Wales) Act 2013 (the 2013 Act) on this issue was examined. In implementation, the application of the ‘reasonable person’ test in the 2013 Act, supported by Human Tissue Authority guidance which refers to ‘evidence’ of a potential donor’s views, provide for the same practice as will be developed in Scotland. The Bill is flexible as it allows any kind of evidence provided by relatives, friends or others with relevant information to be taken into account and does not require that person to “know” the most recent views of the potential donor.
The guidance, supporting the 2013 Act, assists SNODs in assessing the evidence presented to reach a decision as to whether a reasonable person would be satisfied that it represents the potential donor’s views. The intention is to provide similar guidance to support the implementation of the Bill.
The provisions, including the Duty to Inquire provisions, are designed to provide a clear mechanism for inquiries to be made of the relevant people and for those people to be able to bring evidence forward, if necessary. The Bill does not require the evidence to be in any particular form and the provisions are designed to be flexible to allow the Specialist Nurses for Organ Donation (SNODs) and Tissue Donor Co-ordinators to take into account different types of evidence provided and to reach a conclusion as to whether the evidence represents the potential donor’s views.
In developing the Bill, the approach taken in the Human Transplantation (Wales) Act 2013 (the 2013 Act) on this issue was examined. In implementation, the application of the ‘reasonable person’ test in the 2013 Act, supported by Human Tissue Authority guidance which refers to ‘evidence’ of a potential donor’s views, provide for the same practice as will be developed in Scotland. The Bill is flexible as it allows any kind of evidence provided by relatives, friends or others with relevant information to be taken into account and does not require that person to “know” the most recent views of the potential donor.
The guidance, supporting the 2013 Act, assists SNODs in assessing the evidence presented to reach a decision as to whether a reasonable person would be satisfied that it represents the potential donor’s views. The intention is to provide similar guidance to support the implementation of the Bill.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S5W-21891 by reference.