Written Question · S5W-20377 · Session 5
Further to the answer to question S5W-14751 by Roseanna Cunningham on 1 March 2018, what its position is on whether local authorities shoul…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government, further to the answer to question S5W-14751 by Roseanna Cunningham on 1 March 2018, what its position is on whether local authorities should take account of climate change when considering new flood defence systems, and what information it has regarding how many new systems that it has provided funding for in each of the last five years (a) have and (b) have not been subject to such consideration by the relevant councils.
The answer
The Scottish Government provides guidance for responsible authorities on the economic, social and environmental aspects of option appraisal for actions promoted under the Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009. https://www.gov.scot/publications/guidance-support-sepa-responsible-authorities/ . It includes guidance on how to take climate change into account. The Scottish Government does not hold information on what consideration has been given to climate change by local authorities when designing new flood protection schemes.
It is for the local authority to decide on the standard of protection for a proposed scheme based on all the relevant factors. The approach should be risk based, linking benefits to costs with the aim of maximising the reduction in overall risk.
Climate change has not been a specific consideration when making decisions about which flood protection schemes should be funded. In 2012 an arrangement was agreed between the Scottish Government and COSLA whereby the flooding component of the General Capital Grant would be distributed to major projects against a set of eligibility criteria agreed by Scottish Ministers and COSLA. No design standards were applied at this time but schemes had to be able to demonstrate a positive benefit cost ratio of greater than 1 and demonstrate project value for money.
In July 2016 it was agreed by Scottish Ministers and COSLA that from 2016-17 onwards 80% of the flood component of the general capital grant would be allocated to large scale projects and distributed according to the prioritised list of flooding schemes and works set out in the Flood Risk Management Strategies. Schemes proposed in the flood risk management strategies were prioritised according to their cost benefit ratio and taking into account a series of additional criteria, encompassing the environmental and social impacts of flooding. This list was agreed by the National Prioritisation Advisory Group which was chaired by the Scottish Government. It was agreed that for 2016-2021 all the 40 schemes on the prioritised list would receive 80% grant funding if they went ahead.
It is for the local authority to decide on the standard of protection for a proposed scheme based on all the relevant factors. The approach should be risk based, linking benefits to costs with the aim of maximising the reduction in overall risk.
Climate change has not been a specific consideration when making decisions about which flood protection schemes should be funded. In 2012 an arrangement was agreed between the Scottish Government and COSLA whereby the flooding component of the General Capital Grant would be distributed to major projects against a set of eligibility criteria agreed by Scottish Ministers and COSLA. No design standards were applied at this time but schemes had to be able to demonstrate a positive benefit cost ratio of greater than 1 and demonstrate project value for money.
In July 2016 it was agreed by Scottish Ministers and COSLA that from 2016-17 onwards 80% of the flood component of the general capital grant would be allocated to large scale projects and distributed according to the prioritised list of flooding schemes and works set out in the Flood Risk Management Strategies. Schemes proposed in the flood risk management strategies were prioritised according to their cost benefit ratio and taking into account a series of additional criteria, encompassing the environmental and social impacts of flooding. This list was agreed by the National Prioritisation Advisory Group which was chaired by the Scottish Government. It was agreed that for 2016-2021 all the 40 schemes on the prioritised list would receive 80% grant funding if they went ahead.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S5W-20377 by reference.