Written Question · S5W-16923 · Session 5
Whether each of the recommendations set out in the report, Scotland's Choice - report of the Scottish Prisons Commission, which was publish…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government whether each of the recommendations set out in the report, Scotland's Choice
- report of the Scottish Prisons Commission, which was published in July 2008, have been fully implemented and, if not, which remain outstanding, broken down by (a) the reason for the delay and (b) by what date the implementation will be completed.
The answer
Scotland’s Choice made 23 separate recommendations, almost all of which have been incorporated into current Government policy. The Scottish Government’s Justice Vision and Priorities reflects the principles of Scotland’s Choice that the use of prison should be reserved for those whose offences are so serious that no other punishment will do and that our prisons should promote rehabilitation and reintegration. Our wider Community Justice policy priorities are also informed by this report, in particular around the increased use of diversion and community sentences as a way to support reductions in reoffending.
In terms of recommendations which have not been taken forward:The Custodial Sentences and Weapons (Scotland) Act 2007 was not implemented and therefore the recommendation relating to that legislation is no longer relevant.The Scottish Government has retained the practice of Home Detention Curfew (HDC) as an established mechanism for preparing individuals for release. There are no plans to revoke HDC.The Scottish Government has not set a specific target for the prison population nor do we intend to. Nevertheless, we are committed to reducing the use of imprisonment and there are a wide range of actions we are taking that will do this including the increased use of diversion, bail, and community sentences.
In terms of recommendations which have not been taken forward:The Custodial Sentences and Weapons (Scotland) Act 2007 was not implemented and therefore the recommendation relating to that legislation is no longer relevant.The Scottish Government has retained the practice of Home Detention Curfew (HDC) as an established mechanism for preparing individuals for release. There are no plans to revoke HDC.The Scottish Government has not set a specific target for the prison population nor do we intend to. Nevertheless, we are committed to reducing the use of imprisonment and there are a wide range of actions we are taking that will do this including the increased use of diversion, bail, and community sentences.
In the Official Report
1 contribution mention S5W-16923-
15 Jan 2019Topical Question Time
I thank the Cabinet Secretary for Justice for the candour of his response and for his confirmation that, as was the case back in June, the Government is “committed to reducing the use of imprisonment”.—Written Answers, 12 June 2018; S5W-16…