Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S5W-15617 · Session 5

Further to the answer to question S5W-15082 by Maureen Watt on 14 March 2018, whether guidance has been issued that confirms that a person …

Answered Asked by Miles Briggs Con Lodged 23 Mar 2018

The question

To ask the Scottish Government, further to the answer to question S5W-15082 by Maureen Watt on 14 March 2018, whether guidance has been issued that confirms that a person must not be assumed to have Significantly Impaired Decision Making Ability (SIDMA) unless it has been properly established that a mental disorder has affected that person's ability to believe, understand and retain information, and to make and communicate decisions.

The answer

Answered by Maureen Watt on 18 Apr 2018 · 26 days after it was lodged, on time

The Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 sets out the principles according to which those who perform duties under the Act must discharge those functions. This includes professionals such as medical practitioners who take decisions concerning compulsion.
Scottish Ministers are under a duty to prepare, publish and revise a Code of Practice under the 2003 Act. The Code sets out guidance to professionals on their duties, therefore doctors, mental health officers and others exercising statutory functions under the Act are under a duty to have regard to the Code.
Volume 2 of the Code deals with the range of issues relating to civil compulsory powers and includes specific sections that make clear which criteria should be met before the various orders and certificates may be granted. It makes particular mention on the concept of significantly impaired decision making ability (SIDMA), in that: SIDMA must always be linked to a person’s mental disorder but it should not necessarily be taken to be synonymous with mental disorder SIDMA means a significant impairment in relation to decisions about the provision of medical treatment for mental disorder A person’s decision making ability should not be considered to be significantly impaired by reason only of a lack of deficiency in a faculty of communication Similarly, it should not be taken as equivalent to disagreeing with the opinions of professionals
Other forms of guidance are available
- the Mental Welfare Commission have published good practice guides for practitioners on various issues, one of which is called 'Consent to Treatment'. Similarly, the General Medical Council publishes guidance for all UK doctors, entitled 'Consent: patients and doctors making decisions together'.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S5W-15617 by reference.