Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

General Question · S5O-01097 · Session 5

What impact a 50% top rate of income tax would have on public finances.

Answered Asked by Murdo Fraser Con Lodged 30 May 2017

The question

To ask the Scottish Government what impact a 50% top rate of income tax would have on public finances.

The answer

Answered by Derek Mackay on 7 Jun 2017

The Scottish Government has published detailed analysis of the impact of a 50% top rate of income tax in 2017-18 on our website. Revenue forecasts from a 50% rate of income tax are particularly dependent on behavioral effects and so a range of possible revenue impacts was provided. The First Minister has asked the Council of Economic Advisors to consider how and to what extent any revenue risk can be mitigated and we look forward to seeing their report later in the year.
HMRC have indicated that a 5p increase in the additional rate of income tax may raise around £450m in 2018-19 at the whole of UK level. An increase in income tax in the rest of the UK would impact on the Scottish budget through the block grant adjustment and Barnett consequentials depending on how increased revenues were spent.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S5O-01097 by reference.