Portfolio Question · S5O-00311 · Session 5
Whether all crew working on vessels that operate on its contracts or receive support from its subsidies are paid at least the national mini…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government whether all crew working on vessels that operate on its contracts or receive support from its subsidies are paid at least the national minimum wage.
The answer
As the member is aware, following recent media coverage, National Minimum Wage is not currently being paid to the crew on freighters operating the freight service to and from the Northern Isles. These freighters are leased, with crew, from Seatruck to the operator of the Northern Isles Ferry Service, Serco Northlink Ferries.
Employment law is a reserved matter and the European Commission has confirmed that any requirement on contractors, as part of a public procurement process or public contract, to pay their employees a living wage set at a higher rate than the UK’s National Minimum Wage, is unlikely to be compatible with EU law.
I find the current situation unacceptable and have sought further legal advice on the issue. I have also again written to the UK Government, as my predecessor, Keith Brown MSP did in 2014, seeking their intervention in what is a reserved matter given National Minimum Wage legislation.
I have also arranged for a meeting with Seatruck’s CEO tomorrow morning to discuss the matter further.
Crew directly employed by David MacBrayne Ltd, Serco NorthLink Ferries Ltd and Marine Scotland are paid above the National Minimum Wage. I can confirm that David MacBrayne Ltd are a Living Wage employer.
The Scottish Ministers are currently considering all available options to promote fair work practices, including collective bargaining and payment of the National Minimum Wage and, where possible, the Scottish Living Wage in their contracts.
Employment law is a reserved matter and the European Commission has confirmed that any requirement on contractors, as part of a public procurement process or public contract, to pay their employees a living wage set at a higher rate than the UK’s National Minimum Wage, is unlikely to be compatible with EU law.
I find the current situation unacceptable and have sought further legal advice on the issue. I have also again written to the UK Government, as my predecessor, Keith Brown MSP did in 2014, seeking their intervention in what is a reserved matter given National Minimum Wage legislation.
I have also arranged for a meeting with Seatruck’s CEO tomorrow morning to discuss the matter further.
Crew directly employed by David MacBrayne Ltd, Serco NorthLink Ferries Ltd and Marine Scotland are paid above the National Minimum Wage. I can confirm that David MacBrayne Ltd are a Living Wage employer.
The Scottish Ministers are currently considering all available options to promote fair work practices, including collective bargaining and payment of the National Minimum Wage and, where possible, the Scottish Living Wage in their contracts.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S5O-00311 by reference.