Written Question · S4W-28989 · Session 4
What analysis it has carried out of what impact the proposed merger of cleft surgical services might have on (a) programmes to deliver impr…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government what analysis it has carried out of what impact the proposed merger of cleft surgical services might have on (a) programmes to deliver improved speech outcomes and (b) patients who have to travel a greater distance to access an unfamiliar hospital, including possible increases in (i) stress and (ii) time taken off from education or work.
The answer
The National Specialist Services Committee (NSSC) has discussed the outcome of the review group options appraisal which recommends consolidation of the national specialist cleft surgical service to a single site in Glasgow.
The recommendation only applies to the cleft surgical element of cleft services. All other aspects of cleft care will continue to be delivered close to home. No changes are proposed to locally delivered cleft care – such as orthodontics, speech and language therapy, dental services and support from specialist nurses; and there is no suggestion of the withdrawal of specialist outreach clinics.
Cleft Care Scotland, the National Managed Clinical Network, will continue to ensure that every patient with a cleft lip, cleft palate or cleft lip and palate is offered specialist cleft care from diagnosis to adulthood and work with families to offer the right care, in the right place at the right time to produce the best possible outcome for the patient.
If the recommendation is approved, it is expected that this model of care will minimise the impact of change on patient travel and will ensure local care provision, wherever safe and appropriate, with expert input into decisions in local services and treatment for children and adults with cleft lip and/or palate.
However, NSSC has agreed that all stakeholders should have the opportunity to have their views heard. The next steps are:
To consult widely with stakeholders to test the proposed change and to identify any issues that need to be addressed in the implementation of a single cleft surgical service provided by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde;
Consultation will include close working with Cleft Care Scotland, CLAPA and other patients/parents, as well as the staff involved;
That an equality impact assessment is carried out on this proposal.
This will enable the review group to bring a report on the outcomes from the consultation process and a final proposal to NSSC. A fuller communication advising the engagement and consultation process will be issued by National Services Division early in 2016.
The recommendation only applies to the cleft surgical element of cleft services. All other aspects of cleft care will continue to be delivered close to home. No changes are proposed to locally delivered cleft care – such as orthodontics, speech and language therapy, dental services and support from specialist nurses; and there is no suggestion of the withdrawal of specialist outreach clinics.
Cleft Care Scotland, the National Managed Clinical Network, will continue to ensure that every patient with a cleft lip, cleft palate or cleft lip and palate is offered specialist cleft care from diagnosis to adulthood and work with families to offer the right care, in the right place at the right time to produce the best possible outcome for the patient.
If the recommendation is approved, it is expected that this model of care will minimise the impact of change on patient travel and will ensure local care provision, wherever safe and appropriate, with expert input into decisions in local services and treatment for children and adults with cleft lip and/or palate.
However, NSSC has agreed that all stakeholders should have the opportunity to have their views heard. The next steps are:
To consult widely with stakeholders to test the proposed change and to identify any issues that need to be addressed in the implementation of a single cleft surgical service provided by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde;
Consultation will include close working with Cleft Care Scotland, CLAPA and other patients/parents, as well as the staff involved;
That an equality impact assessment is carried out on this proposal.
This will enable the review group to bring a report on the outcomes from the consultation process and a final proposal to NSSC. A fuller communication advising the engagement and consultation process will be issued by National Services Division early in 2016.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-28989 by reference.