Written Question · S4W-25248 · Session 4
What discussions it has had with the UK Government in each year since 2007 regarding the future of the Longannet power station.
The question
To ask the Scottish Government what discussions it has had with the UK Government in each year since 2007 regarding the future of the Longannet power station.
The answer
The Scottish Government has consistently argued throughout the Scottish National Party administration for reform of the UK transmission charging regime introduced by the Labour government in 2005 that unfairly penalises Scottish generators such as Longannet.
Transmission charging and the important role Longannet plays in security of supply were discussed at a meeting of the Scottish Energy Advisory Board chaired by the First Minister on 16 February 2015. The First Minister subsequently exchanged letters with the Prime Minister in February and March 2015 highlighting Scottish Government concerns about Longannet’s future and the need for the Scottish Parliament and government to have oversight of the analysis and subsequent decisions which affect the security of Scotland’s electricity supply.
Under the devolved settlement, governmental and regulatory responsibility and operational control of UK energy market issues rests with the UK Government, Ofgem and National Grid. The actions urgently required on the key factors contributing to the threat of premature closure of Longannet – principally, transmission charges and the design of the UK Capacity Market – are ones that must be taken by the relevant UK authorities rather than the Scottish Government.
A chronology of recent discussions and correspondence led by the myself relating to Longannet is listed in the following table.
Date
Activity
6 October 2014
I wrote to the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change requesting urgent talks on Longannet.
7 October 2014
I had a telephone call with Neil Clitheroe (Chief Executive Officer, Scottish Power Retail and Generation) and discussed the future of Longannet.
Topical Question S4T-00804: ‘To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking regarding the future of Longannet power station’ was answered by myself in the Scottish Parliament.
22 October 2014
I had a telephone call with Neil Clitheroe and had another discussion on the future of Longannet.
12 November 2014
I co-chaired a meeting of the Thermal Generation and Carbon Capture and Storage Industry Leadership Group. The state of the electricity sector was discussed, focusing on supply margins.
14 November 2014
I wrote to Steve Holliday, the Chief Executive Officer of National Grid, following the publication of the company’s winter outlook report. National Grid was asked to explain how it assesses the role Longannet has to play in ensuring an adequate level of security of supply in Scotland.
26 November 2014
I met with Mike Calviou, Director of Transmission Network Service at National Grid, to discuss the future of Longannet and the emerging findings of National Grid’s system study for Scotland.
21 January 2015
I met with Keith Anderson (Chief Corporate Officer, Scottish Power), Frank Mitchell (Chief Executive Officer, SP Energy Networks) and Neil Clitheroe. Discussions included the future of Longannet.
23 February 2015
I visited Longannet and met with representatives of Scottish Power and the union Prospect.
25 February 2015
I had a telephone call with the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change and discussed the future of Longannet.
13 March 2015
I had a telephone call with Mike Calviou and sought answers to the many concerns about security of supply in Scotland including Longannet’s future.
19 March 2015
I met with Mike Calviou in London and sought reassurances that National Grid was recognising the full value of Longannet.
26 March 2015
I met with representatives of the Scottish Trades Union Congress, Prospect, GMB, Unite, Unison, ASLEF and RMT at the Scottish Parliament to explore possible actions to avert or mitigate premature closure of Longannet.
Transmission charging and the important role Longannet plays in security of supply were discussed at a meeting of the Scottish Energy Advisory Board chaired by the First Minister on 16 February 2015. The First Minister subsequently exchanged letters with the Prime Minister in February and March 2015 highlighting Scottish Government concerns about Longannet’s future and the need for the Scottish Parliament and government to have oversight of the analysis and subsequent decisions which affect the security of Scotland’s electricity supply.
Under the devolved settlement, governmental and regulatory responsibility and operational control of UK energy market issues rests with the UK Government, Ofgem and National Grid. The actions urgently required on the key factors contributing to the threat of premature closure of Longannet – principally, transmission charges and the design of the UK Capacity Market – are ones that must be taken by the relevant UK authorities rather than the Scottish Government.
A chronology of recent discussions and correspondence led by the myself relating to Longannet is listed in the following table.
Date
Activity
6 October 2014
I wrote to the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change requesting urgent talks on Longannet.
7 October 2014
I had a telephone call with Neil Clitheroe (Chief Executive Officer, Scottish Power Retail and Generation) and discussed the future of Longannet.
Topical Question S4T-00804: ‘To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking regarding the future of Longannet power station’ was answered by myself in the Scottish Parliament.
22 October 2014
I had a telephone call with Neil Clitheroe and had another discussion on the future of Longannet.
12 November 2014
I co-chaired a meeting of the Thermal Generation and Carbon Capture and Storage Industry Leadership Group. The state of the electricity sector was discussed, focusing on supply margins.
14 November 2014
I wrote to Steve Holliday, the Chief Executive Officer of National Grid, following the publication of the company’s winter outlook report. National Grid was asked to explain how it assesses the role Longannet has to play in ensuring an adequate level of security of supply in Scotland.
26 November 2014
I met with Mike Calviou, Director of Transmission Network Service at National Grid, to discuss the future of Longannet and the emerging findings of National Grid’s system study for Scotland.
21 January 2015
I met with Keith Anderson (Chief Corporate Officer, Scottish Power), Frank Mitchell (Chief Executive Officer, SP Energy Networks) and Neil Clitheroe. Discussions included the future of Longannet.
23 February 2015
I visited Longannet and met with representatives of Scottish Power and the union Prospect.
25 February 2015
I had a telephone call with the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change and discussed the future of Longannet.
13 March 2015
I had a telephone call with Mike Calviou and sought answers to the many concerns about security of supply in Scotland including Longannet’s future.
19 March 2015
I met with Mike Calviou in London and sought reassurances that National Grid was recognising the full value of Longannet.
26 March 2015
I met with representatives of the Scottish Trades Union Congress, Prospect, GMB, Unite, Unison, ASLEF and RMT at the Scottish Parliament to explore possible actions to avert or mitigate premature closure of Longannet.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-25248 by reference.