Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S4W-24187 · Session 4

 how many closures of the Skye Bridge to (a) high-sided vehicles and (b) all vehicles there have been since September 2014.

Answered Asked by David Stewart Lab Lodged 27 Jan 2015

The question

To ask the Scottish Government how many closures of the Skye Bridge to (a) high-sided vehicles and (b) all vehicles there have been since September 2014.

The answer

Answered by Derek Mackay on 9 Feb 2015 · 13 days after it was lodged, on time

Statistics about closures of the Skye Bridge are contained in the following table:
Time Period
Number of Closures of the Skye Bridge to High-Sided Vehicles
Number of Closures of the Skye Bridge to All Vehicles
2012
30
0
2013
54
1
2014
97
11
September 2014 to January 2015
97
14

The above data is based on records of triggers automatically generated by the instrumentation on the bridge, which prompts signing by Traffic Scotland and closure of the bridge when the appropriate threshold is reached. In some cases, especially recently, wind speeds have varied substantially over relatively short time periods, resulting in rapid change from one state to another and back again. To reflect these factors in the case of full closures, these have been grouped into one closure event.
The wind management plan for the bridge requires that it is closed to high-sided vehicles when the wind gust speed exceeds 50 mph and closed to all vehicles when it exceeds 75 mph. These trigger thresholds have not been formally reconsidered for change since they were first established around 2004. In part, this is due to experience that they were operating well. They are designed as much as possible to ensure the safety of the public, whilst minimising disturbance to the movement of traffic.
However, in the light of increased wind events and resultant restrictions since September 2014, Transport Scotland has been working with its operating company BEAR Scotland to consider all aspects of the plan with a view to bringing forward any appropriate improvements. The thresholds, contingency planning and possible additional infrastructure are included in this exercise.
Transport Scotland will report in full when all aspects have been considered and discussed with stakeholders, in particular the Highland Council and Police Scotland, with whom the legal authority to close the bridge lies. Safety will remain the overriding principle.
The location of the Skye Bridge measuring equipment has recently been discussed with our operating company BEAR Scotland and their equipment supplier, Vaisala. The location should represent the likely highest winds that drivers would encounter over their entire crossing journey. A wind profile study undertaken by the previous operating company identified that the current location meets that criteria, hence the interim advice is that it should remain where it is.
There has been no specific economic assessment of the impact of closure. However, in seeking to ensure the safety of the public whilst minimising disturbance to the movement of traffic the Scottish Government recognises the importance of the bridge to the people and economy of Skye and beyond.
We will report on the outcome of our analysis outlined above in due course. In the meantime, BEAR Scotland has improved communications with stakeholders by adopting a system of automatically generated email messages when trigger thresholds are reached.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-24187 by reference.