Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S4W-24029 · Session 4

What assessment it has made of the impact on public spending if Scotland achieves full fiscal autonomy and the block grant funding mechanis…

Answered Asked by Jackie Baillie Lab Lodged 15 Jan 2015

The question

To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the impact on public spending if Scotland achieves full fiscal autonomy and the block grant funding mechanism is ended.

The answer

Answered by John Swinney on 27 Jan 2015 · 12 days after it was lodged, on time

Scotland has a strong fiscal base; in every one of the last 33 years, tax receipts have been higher per head in Scotland than the UK. Even when oil revenues are excluded, tax revenues per person in Scotland are broadly in line with the UK.
Under full fiscal autonomy, Scotland would still remain part of the UK and would negotiate its share of reserved spending and the operation of payments towards these.
In its submission to The Smith Commission, the Scottish Government outlined its proposals for ‘More Powers for the Scottish Parliament.’ These proposals included full fiscal autonomy which, if implemented, would have led to all tax revenues being retained in Scotland. The Smith Commission published its recommendations on 27 November 2014, and subsequently the UK Government published an overview of its proposals on 22 January 2015. The Smith Commission did not recommend full fiscal autonomy, and currently there are no plans to legislate for full fiscal devolution to the Scottish Parliament. While the Smith Commission recommendations did not go as far as what the Scottish Government recommended, and do not live up to the ‘vow’ made before the independence referendum, the Scottish Government welcomes further powers, and they must now be delivered. The Scottish Government is focused on making Scotland a more prosperous country, tackling inequality and protecting our public services, and the new powers being delivered must help deliver those goals.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-24029 by reference.