Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Inspired Question · S4W-23695 · Session 4

Whether it will provide an update on its review of spectator safety at motor sport events, which was set up following the incidents at the …

Answered Arranged question: government announcement Asked by Joan McAlpine SNP Lodged 16 Dec 2014

The question

To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on its review of spectator safety at motor sport events, which was set up following the incidents at the 2014 Jim Clark Rally.

The answer

Answered by Jamie Hepburn on 6 Jan 2015 · 21 days after it was lodged, on time

The review group on motor sport event safety began work in June 2014 following the tragic deaths of three people and injuries to several others at the Jim Clark Rally in 2014. A spectator had also been killed and another injured at the Highland Snowman Rally the previous year.
The group was established by the Scottish Government to ‘Examine safety, specifically spectator safety, at motor sport events in Scotland and make recommendations to improve safety for future events.’
The group is chaired by the Scottish Government and has a wide membership including representatives of the Motor Sports Association (MSA), Scottish Auto Cycle Union, Police Scotland, the Health & Safety Executive and a local authority. The group has been advised by Sir Jackie Stewart.
The group has not considered the particular circumstances of the accidents at the Jim Clark and Highland Snowman rallies as these are subject to open investigations by Police Scotland, the Health & Safety Executive and the Crown Office.
The immediate priority was to consider safety at multi-venue stage rallies. This is the main type of rally in Scotland and uses linked sections of forest or public road covering many miles. Only two rallies in Scotland currently use public roads – the Jim Clark Rally and the Mull Rally. There are a number of forest rallies including the nine Scottish Championship events. Interim recommendations were announced in October 2014 prior to the Mull Rally. The group has now submitted final recommendations on multi-venue stage rallies.
The group will consider other areas of two, three and four wheeled motor sport early this year.
I am delighted with this important work by the review group. Key proposals, such as the introduction of an MSA licensing scheme and training for marshals, a press accreditation scheme, the liaison between rally organisers and Police Scotland at local level and the tightening up of measures such as the use of safety plans, spectator safety officers and course cars represents a significant package and a step forward in reducing the risks to spectators.
We want to see motorsports continue in Scotland in as safe a manner as possible so that the many people who enjoy this sport can continue to do so. We do not want to deter people from volunteering to marshal at rallies – it is clear that the sport will continue to be dependent on the significant input of dedicated, enthusiastic and knowledgeable volunteers. However, we need to ensure that there is an appropriate level of regulation by the sport’s governing body, the MSA, of the contribution of those volunteers.
The Scottish Government is fully committed to working with the MSA going forward on the transitional and full implementation of the review group’s recommendations in a sensible and proportionate way. The Scottish Government is grateful for their co-operation and for the input of the Federation Internationale de l’Automobile (FIA) to the review.
I am also very grateful to all members of the group who have delivered these recommendations in a very short timescale, reflecting the urgency we attach to improving spectator safety.
It is highly appropriate that our initiative on spectator safety in Scotland should set a standard that can be followed by others given the high level contribution Scotland has made to motorsports including our champions across a number of motorsports disciplines such as Sir Jackie Stewart OBE, Dario Franchitti, Allan McNish, David Coulthard, Gordon Shedden and, Steve Hislop and, in rallying, Colin McRae, his father Jimmy McRae, Robert Reid, Louise Aitken-Walker and David Bogie among others. We want to ensure that the sport continues to develop young talent but matched by a responsible and forward-thinking approach to spectator safety.
I expect the work of the group to provide a model that can be further discussed at international level with the FIA.
A short statement from the review group appears below and the full set of recommendations

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-23695 by reference.