Written Question · S4W-20739 · Session 4
Further to the answer to question S4W-20469 by Fergus Ewing on 14 April 2014, whether it will publish its letter to the UK Government of (a…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government, further to the answer to question S4W-20469 by Fergus Ewing on 14 April 2014, whether it will publish its letter to the UK Government of (a) 18 June 2012 and (b) 11 September 2012 regarding VAT on ski-lifts.
The answer
The text of the letter from the Minister for Energy, Enterprise and Tourism to the UK Chief Secretary to the Treasury, issued on 18 June 2012, is as follows:
“I welcomed the UK Government's budget decision to reduce to 5% the VAT applied on cable operated transport systems, including ski lifts. When introduced, this reduction will bring our VAT rate into line with that applied elsewhere in the European Union and, in removing that competitive disadvantage, should bring a small, but much needed, boost to Scotland's five snows ports centres.
I am, however, concerned by the proposed timing of the change, which we understand is not to be made until April 2013. I wonder if you could give some further thought to the timing, particularly whether the reduction could be introduced at the beginning of January 2013, very slightly earlier than is currently proposed.
The small change in timing will make a considerable difference to the centres whom I met recently to reflect on the last season and the challenges ahead of them. As you will understand, the centres see the reduction in VAT as key to releasing vital resources that they can invest in their future sustainability. All the centres have planned improvements which they hoped to fund with released resources, including upgrading machinery such as piste machines and gondola motors, replacing .lifts and building projects to house machinery. Without resources, they simply cannot afford to implement their plans. Unfortunately, the current timetable would mean that the reduction would not be made until after the end of the next snowsports season, with the centres not seeing any real benefits until 2014. Given the need for essential maintenance and the urgency in starting the process of upgrading and replacing ageing infrastructure at the centres, an earlier introduction is key to ensure the intended impact of the Chancellor's Budget decision comes into effect sooner rather than later.
There is one further aspect of the VAT decision which has been brought to my attention by the centres: the status of travelator lifts. The wording in the budget statement does not mention travelator lifts, which perform the same function of transporting skiers but in a safer manner, and clarification on their status. In respect of VAT would be greatly appreciated, not least since it is likely that travelators will progressively replace some of the smaller wire tows for safety reasons.
I know that you recognise the substantial contribution that this iconic industry makes to the Scottish economy, generating around £30 million a year and supporting over 600 jobs, often in very fragile communities. Our natural resources, scenery and tourist infrastructure combine to make Scotland a first class destination for global snowsports. I hope that you will be able to review the timetable to make the small change necessary to support the sector's survival.
I look forward to your response.”
The text of the letter from the Minister for Energy, Enterprise and Tourism to the UK Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury, issued on 11 September 2012, is as follows:
“I welcome your letter of 18 July 2012 setting out HM Treasury's position with regard to travelator lifts and the legislative timing of the rate of 5% VAT on cable-suspended passenger transport.
Your advice on travelators was extremely helpful and, while this will obviously be disappointing to the one Scottish centre which operates this mechanism, it has certainly clarified the distinction between those transport systems which will benefit from the reduced rate and those which fall outwith the eligibility criteria.
I know that Scotland's main economic development agencies, Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise, have responded to the ongoing HM Customs and Revenue consultation about the timing of the introduction of the reduced VAT rate. I am sure that there will be further responses, not least from the five snowsports centres for whom an early in
“I welcomed the UK Government's budget decision to reduce to 5% the VAT applied on cable operated transport systems, including ski lifts. When introduced, this reduction will bring our VAT rate into line with that applied elsewhere in the European Union and, in removing that competitive disadvantage, should bring a small, but much needed, boost to Scotland's five snows ports centres.
I am, however, concerned by the proposed timing of the change, which we understand is not to be made until April 2013. I wonder if you could give some further thought to the timing, particularly whether the reduction could be introduced at the beginning of January 2013, very slightly earlier than is currently proposed.
The small change in timing will make a considerable difference to the centres whom I met recently to reflect on the last season and the challenges ahead of them. As you will understand, the centres see the reduction in VAT as key to releasing vital resources that they can invest in their future sustainability. All the centres have planned improvements which they hoped to fund with released resources, including upgrading machinery such as piste machines and gondola motors, replacing .lifts and building projects to house machinery. Without resources, they simply cannot afford to implement their plans. Unfortunately, the current timetable would mean that the reduction would not be made until after the end of the next snowsports season, with the centres not seeing any real benefits until 2014. Given the need for essential maintenance and the urgency in starting the process of upgrading and replacing ageing infrastructure at the centres, an earlier introduction is key to ensure the intended impact of the Chancellor's Budget decision comes into effect sooner rather than later.
There is one further aspect of the VAT decision which has been brought to my attention by the centres: the status of travelator lifts. The wording in the budget statement does not mention travelator lifts, which perform the same function of transporting skiers but in a safer manner, and clarification on their status. In respect of VAT would be greatly appreciated, not least since it is likely that travelators will progressively replace some of the smaller wire tows for safety reasons.
I know that you recognise the substantial contribution that this iconic industry makes to the Scottish economy, generating around £30 million a year and supporting over 600 jobs, often in very fragile communities. Our natural resources, scenery and tourist infrastructure combine to make Scotland a first class destination for global snowsports. I hope that you will be able to review the timetable to make the small change necessary to support the sector's survival.
I look forward to your response.”
The text of the letter from the Minister for Energy, Enterprise and Tourism to the UK Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury, issued on 11 September 2012, is as follows:
“I welcome your letter of 18 July 2012 setting out HM Treasury's position with regard to travelator lifts and the legislative timing of the rate of 5% VAT on cable-suspended passenger transport.
Your advice on travelators was extremely helpful and, while this will obviously be disappointing to the one Scottish centre which operates this mechanism, it has certainly clarified the distinction between those transport systems which will benefit from the reduced rate and those which fall outwith the eligibility criteria.
I know that Scotland's main economic development agencies, Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise, have responded to the ongoing HM Customs and Revenue consultation about the timing of the introduction of the reduced VAT rate. I am sure that there will be further responses, not least from the five snowsports centres for whom an early in
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-20739 by reference.