Written Question · S4W-20052 · Session 4
Further to the answer to question S4W-19909 by Roseanna Cunningham on 6 March 2014, for what reasons it did not propose the abolition of ho…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government, further to the answer to question S4W-19909 by Roseanna Cunningham on 6 March 2014, for what reasons it did not propose the abolition of honorary sheriffs in its consultation on the Courts Reform (Scotland) Bill and how many respondents to the consultation called for their abolition.
The answer
The proposals in the draft Courts Reform (Scotland) Bill consulted upon in 2013 included restricting the civil competence of the honorary sheriff to that of the new summary sheriff.
The Scottish Government has listened to the representations it has received on its proposals in relation to honorary sheriffs and amended its proposals accordingly.
There were several negative comments from stakeholders responding to the consultation. In particular, there were comments that the appointment process for honorary sheriffs was not considered transparent, that honorary sheriffs may not be suitably qualified to deal with family law cases, and that the post of honorary sheriff should not be elevated to a statutory judicial office. One consultee said that no person should be allowed to sit as a sheriff in civil cases involving child welfare and domestic abuse unless they had 10 years legal qualification (i.e. this would preclude honorary sheriffs from doing so). Another body said that some of its members thought that honorary sheriffs had no place in our system and that the proposals should be reconsidered.
The Scottish Government will not abolish honorary sheriffs until alternative arrangements including summary sheriffs and technology are in place.
The Scottish Government has listened to the representations it has received on its proposals in relation to honorary sheriffs and amended its proposals accordingly.
There were several negative comments from stakeholders responding to the consultation. In particular, there were comments that the appointment process for honorary sheriffs was not considered transparent, that honorary sheriffs may not be suitably qualified to deal with family law cases, and that the post of honorary sheriff should not be elevated to a statutory judicial office. One consultee said that no person should be allowed to sit as a sheriff in civil cases involving child welfare and domestic abuse unless they had 10 years legal qualification (i.e. this would preclude honorary sheriffs from doing so). Another body said that some of its members thought that honorary sheriffs had no place in our system and that the proposals should be reconsidered.
The Scottish Government will not abolish honorary sheriffs until alternative arrangements including summary sheriffs and technology are in place.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-20052 by reference.