Inspired Question · S4W-15574 · Session 4
How many carbon units will be credited to or debited from the 2012 net Scottish emissions account as a result of the operation of the EU Em…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government how many carbon units will be credited to or debited from the 2012 net Scottish emissions account as a result of the operation of the EU Emissions Trading System.
The answer
Aviation emissions have been included in the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) since January 2012 and therefore, unlike the calculations made for 2010 and 2011, the calculation for 2012 must take account of both the traded sector and aviation.
Under the EU ETS, airlines surrender carbon units in relation to all their reportable emissions at a single operational hub and, very few airlines have registered Scotland as their operational hub. As a result the number of carbon units surrendered in respect of Scotland to the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (SEPA) is far smaller than total Scottish aviation emissions. In addition, the controversial inclusion of international flights within the EU ETS resulted in “stop the clock” provisions being introduced to enable flights starting/ending outside the EU to be temporarily excluded from the EU ETS in 2012.
In order to calculate the amount of carbon units to be credited to or debited from the net Scottish emissions account, Scottish Ministers are only able to take account of carbon units surrendered in Scotland to SEPA. The effect is that emissions in Scotland that have been cancelled by surrenders elsewhere in the EU are counted in Scotland as if there had been no such surrender, which means that the amount of aviation emissions in Scotland in 2012 will appear in the account to be greater than they actually are.
As a result of using the current methodology, carrying out the calculation as required by Regulation 8 of the Carbon Accounting Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2010 leads to the effect of aviation emissions being over-stated in the account.
Even so, Scottish Ministers have as required made the calculation under the 2010 Regulations. Scottish Ministers have calculated that in relation to the operation of the EU Emissions Trading System in Scotland during 2012, 4,197,158 units will be debited from the 2012 net Scottish emissions account.
This is a provisional calculation and the Scottish Government will improve the methodology used to make the calculation in the 2010 Regulations so as to provide a more accurate calculation for aviation emissions from 2012 onwards, and intends to bring forward regulations for that purpose prior to the publication of the 2012 annual report in 2014.
Under the EU ETS, airlines surrender carbon units in relation to all their reportable emissions at a single operational hub and, very few airlines have registered Scotland as their operational hub. As a result the number of carbon units surrendered in respect of Scotland to the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (SEPA) is far smaller than total Scottish aviation emissions. In addition, the controversial inclusion of international flights within the EU ETS resulted in “stop the clock” provisions being introduced to enable flights starting/ending outside the EU to be temporarily excluded from the EU ETS in 2012.
In order to calculate the amount of carbon units to be credited to or debited from the net Scottish emissions account, Scottish Ministers are only able to take account of carbon units surrendered in Scotland to SEPA. The effect is that emissions in Scotland that have been cancelled by surrenders elsewhere in the EU are counted in Scotland as if there had been no such surrender, which means that the amount of aviation emissions in Scotland in 2012 will appear in the account to be greater than they actually are.
As a result of using the current methodology, carrying out the calculation as required by Regulation 8 of the Carbon Accounting Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2010 leads to the effect of aviation emissions being over-stated in the account.
Even so, Scottish Ministers have as required made the calculation under the 2010 Regulations. Scottish Ministers have calculated that in relation to the operation of the EU Emissions Trading System in Scotland during 2012, 4,197,158 units will be debited from the 2012 net Scottish emissions account.
This is a provisional calculation and the Scottish Government will improve the methodology used to make the calculation in the 2010 Regulations so as to provide a more accurate calculation for aviation emissions from 2012 onwards, and intends to bring forward regulations for that purpose prior to the publication of the 2012 annual report in 2014.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-15574 by reference.