Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S4W-14002 · Session 4

Whether it has sought legal advice on breaches of state aid rules in relation to the contracts for the Forth Road Bridge and the new crossi…

Answered Asked by David Stewart Lab Lodged 27 Mar 2013

The question

To ask the Scottish Government whether it has sought legal advice on breaches of state aid rules in relation to the contracts for the Forth Road Bridge and the new crossing and what its position is on expanding the Forth Estuary Transport Authority so that it can manage both bridges.

The answer

Answered by Keith Brown on 24 Apr 2013 · 28 days after it was lodged, on time

The Scottish Government draws on oral and written legal advice as appropriate from its lawyers, from Counsel, from external solicitors and from Law Officers. However, other than in exceptional circumstances, the Scottish Government does not comment on the source of such advice, and the content of any legal advice remains confidential. Only the European Commission (or European Courts if needed) can provide a definitive position on matters of State Aid.
To permit statutory responsibility for managing and maintaining the new Forth Crossing to be delegated to FETA by Scottish Ministers, a comprehensive redrawing of its functions would first have been necessary as that power is not contained in the 2002 Order that establishes FETA. There would have been a serious risk that delegating the functions to FETA would have been perceived as being uncompetitive as the market had not been tested. Without testing the market, value for money cannot be demonstrated. Conversely, the Forth Road Bridge Bill offers certainty of tenure for all existing FETA staff, and indeed the prospect of cost efficient job opportunities for new staff.
The Explanatory Notes to the Bill explain that Scottish Ministers’ preferred option is for the implementation of a twin bridge maintenance strategy with a single Forth Bridge Operating Company. The Notes also explain that Ministers rejected the option to involve FETA in operating both Road Bridges. As the new route is a motorway and the new bridge is a wholly different type, a substantial and unforeseen burden would have been placed on the Board, which had not been established for this purpose.
Further information is available within the Explanatory Notes, and Transport Scotland’s formal response to the Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee Report on the Bill, and Stage 1 Debate.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-14002 by reference.