Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Inspired Question · S4W-05327 · Session 4

Whether it will legislate to ensure that, where a person was diagnosed with pleural plaques and did not initiate a claim for damages within…

Answered Arranged question: government announcement Asked by Stuart McMillan SNP Lodged 30 Jan 2012

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will legislate to ensure that, where a person was diagnosed with pleural plaques and did not initiate a claim for damages within three years, a claim for damages for mesothelioma or other distinct asbestos-related diseases would not be time-barred if that condition was subsequently diagnosed.

The answer

Answered by Kenny MacAskill on 31 Jan 2012 · 1 day after it was lodged, on time

In the course of the judicial review of the Damages (Asbestos-related Conditions) (Scotland) Act 2009, it was suggested by the petitioners that “any person found to have asymptomatic plaques would be obliged to raise an action within three years, or risk losing his right of action should he develop symptomatic asbestos-related disease after the expiry of that period”. In making that suggestion, the petitioners appeared to rely on their interpretation of the implications of the decision of the Inner House in Aitchison v. Glasgow City Council [2010], which overruled an earlier decision of the Inner House in Carnegie v. Lord Advocate [2001]. However, the 2010 decision, which was issued some months after the 2009 act came into force, does not refer directly to that legislation.
The future interpretation of the law is a matter for the courts, which will have regard to all relevant facts and circumstances. To date, however, there is understood to have been no specific ruling from the courts that the decision in Aitchison, which related to a relatively recent diagnosis of psychological injury following a much earlier physical injury, would necessarily be interpreted as meaning that claims for damages for a different asbestos-related disease, such as mesothelioma, would be time-barred if there had been no claim for damages following a diagnosis of pleural plaques more than three years previously. Still less has there been any specific ruling from the courts that, even if that were the interpretation, they would also conclude that is would not be equitable to exercise their discretion under section 19A of the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973 to allow a claim for damages for that distinct disease to proceed.
Moreover, as regards future industry practice, the Scottish Government is aware that the Association of British Insurers has given repeated assurances of “insurers continued commitment to pay compensation to people with asbestos-related diseases, such as mesothelioma, which impact on their health”.
At this point, therefore, an imperative for legislation on this issue has not been established. However, the Scottish Government will keep the position under review, in order to determine whether – in advance of the forthcoming consultation exercise which will inform our planned modernisation of the law on damages for personal injury – any specific elements of our modernisation agenda require to be accelerated. Pending the outcome of that consultation exercise, the Scottish Government’s policy view remains that, as was understood to be the case when the 2009 act was passed, a claim for damages for mesothelioma should not be rejected simply because the limitation period for a claim for damages for pleural plaques has expired.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-05327 by reference.