Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S4W-02256 · Session 4

Whether it will publish the full risk assessment which led NHS Scotland to decide not to run a catch-up campaign to immunise teenagers who …

Answered Asked by Dr Richard Simpson Lab Lodged 18 Aug 2011

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will publish the full risk assessment which led NHS Scotland to decide not to run a catch-up campaign to immunise teenagers who are unprotected from the risk of measles, in light of the Health Protection Agency in England deciding to run such a campaign.

The answer

Answered by Michael Matheson on 7 Sep 2011 · 20 days after it was lodged, on time

The English MMR catch-up campaign, which was launched in 2008, was targeted at all young people aged three years and seven months to under 18, and those over 18 going to higher/further education. The campaign was phased, with the youngest age groups being the first priority. The catch-up was driven in part by the low levels of vaccine uptake across England, but particularly the very low levels of uptake of MMR vaccine in London. In 2008-09 uptake of MMR at 24 months in London was as low as 76.3%.
By comparison, uptake of vaccine in Scotland has never fallen as low. Indeed, although there has been an increase in MMR uptake in England, uptake remains lower than in Scotland, where quarterly uptake at 24 months is consistently around the 93%. By comparison, in 2009-10 uptake in England at the same point was 88.2%. It is also unclear how much of this improvement in England was down to the catch-up itself as, at the same time as the catch-up data improvement activity was taking place, with previously given doses being updated onto child health systems.
In Scotland, following a 2005 risk assessment by Health Protection Scotland (HPS) carried, the agreed priority was to focus MMR immunisation efforts on pre-school children to ensure that a high proportion of children were immunised with first dose of MMR (MMR1) by the age of two years. This activity was augmented with action to immunise as many children as possible who had not taken up their first routine dose with MMR1 before the age of six, and by a HEAT target of 95% uptake of at least one dose of MMR by age five (i.e. before starting school).
In 2008, when the Department of Health launched its catch-up campaign, the uptake of MMR1 was very good in Scotland (94.9% of children had received MMR1 by the age of five, and 89.2% had received both doses) and there was no evidence of measles circulating in the Scottish population. The risk assessment was not repeated at that time, as the findings from the previous work in 2005 were still considered valid. In addition, action had been taken in 2004 in response to the emergence of mumps in teenagers and young adults to bolster immunisation levels in those aged 13 to 25, by asking GPs to opportunistically offer MMR to all those in this age range.
Earlier this year it became clear that there was significant transmission of measles in Western Europe among young adults. As a result a further assessment of the risk of measles in this group was undertaken by HPS. The Minister for Public Health has considered this assessment and has discussed it with HPS.
HPS are currently exploring options for the publication of this risk assessment. Meantime the risk assessment (and its companion paper on the options for management of measles susceptibility in Scotland), will be placed into SPICE, once they have been finalised through the HPS document approval process. This is expected to be completed by the end of September.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-02256 by reference.