Portfolio Question · S4O-02202 · Session 4
What assessment it has made of the proposals to close Arbroath and Stonehaven sheriff courts and the impact on communities in Angus and Kin…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the proposals to close Arbroath and Stonehaven sheriff courts and the impact on communities in Angus and Kincardine-shire.
The answer
The Scottish Court Service consultation Shaping Scotland’s Court Services represents a very thorough assessment of the context and the challenge of providing services and facilities across Scotland which are consistent with the standards of a modern court system within the financial constraints imposed by the Westminster Government. The existing network of courts reflects more the social and economic needs of the Victorian age, but in the modern world it is more appropriate to devote the available reduced budget to a smaller number of courts, supplemented by new technology such as video links.
I have deliberated very carefully on the options presented, particularly in view of the representations made in relation to particular courts, and the Cabinet has given its consent to the proposals. We think that the proposals strike the correct balance in the current economic climate.
We realise that a court can be regarded as an important element in communities such as Arbroath and Stonehaven, but this needs to be balanced against the fact that many similar and larger communities function without a local court. We believe that the economic and community impact will be localised and short term.
I have deliberated very carefully on the options presented, particularly in view of the representations made in relation to particular courts, and the Cabinet has given its consent to the proposals. We think that the proposals strike the correct balance in the current economic climate.
We realise that a court can be regarded as an important element in communities such as Arbroath and Stonehaven, but this needs to be balanced against the fact that many similar and larger communities function without a local court. We believe that the economic and community impact will be localised and short term.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4O-02202 by reference.