Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S3W-37968 · Session 3

What assessment it is making of the need to reassess the single farm payments of farmers and crofters whose stock densities during the paym…

Answered Asked by Tavish Scott LD Lodged 30 Nov 2010

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive what assessment it is making of the need to reassess the single farm payments of farmers and crofters whose stock densities during the payment reference period were reduced as a result of an Environmentally Sensitive Area Scheme agreement or another conservation agreement and the outcome of the recent Court of Appeal case of Regina (TA Gwillim & Sons) v Welsh Ministers and what action it will take if any reassessment finds that a backdated increase in payments is due.

The answer

Answered by Richard Lochhead on 23 Dec 2010 · 23 days after it was lodged, 8 days after it was due

My officials are studying the judgement in the case of between The Queen (on the application of TA Gwillim and Sons) and the Welsh Ministers as delivered by the Court of Appeal. Although the overall judgement was in favour of Messrs Gwillim, it also upheld part of the original decision made following the original hearing that it was not sufficient simply to be under an agri-environmental commitment but the producer had to show that production had been adversely affected. That principle was as the heart of the Scottish arrangements to address applications for relief because stock levels had been affected by either hardship or agri-environment conditions or both. This is clearly not a straightforward issue, hence the need to study the judgement carefully. I will write to you separately with our findings and although it is too soon to indicate what they might be; our guiding principle is that Scottish producers should be treated no worse than their Welsh counterparts.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S3W-37968 by reference.