Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S3W-25987 · Session 3

Further to the answers to questions S3W-24192 and S3W-25161 by Roseanna Cunningham on 8 June and 2 July 2009 respectively, what the reason …

Answered Asked by Peter Peacock Lab Lodged 21 Jul 2009

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answers to questions S3W-24192 and S3W-25161 by Roseanna Cunningham on 8 June and 2 July 2009 respectively, what the reason is for the variance between the estimated cost to the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) as stated in Flooding Bill Financial Implications Assessment, the report compiled by MWH on behalf of the Scottish Government and published in September 2008, of £10.82 million until 2011 and the £3.34 million estimate stated in the answers and the financial memorandum that accompanied the Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Bill.

The answer

Answered by Roseanna Cunningham on 14 Aug 2009 · 24 days after it was lodged, on time

I am happy to clarify that the figures contained in the Financial Implications Assessment compiled by MWH were based on preliminary estimates by SEPA. These preliminary figures were revised by SEPA once further discussion over the nature of SEPA''s role and the scope and scale of the work required up to 2011 had taken place. These figures, therefore, quickly became outdated and have been replaced by the figures set out in the financial memorandum and the accompanying supplemental note to the finance committee.
Revisions to the figures focused on aligning the funding to key tasks and deadlines. It is worth noting that reductions over the period up to 2011 in the financial memo are accompanied by increases in costs over the subsequent years of the cycle. This reflects changes to how funding is expected to deliver key tasks, rather than a significant overall reduction in the cost estimate.
The SEPA costs set out in the MWH assessment also included costs for data licences. The government subsequently incorporated these costs into its implementation costs for the Act as it was felt that this approach would be more cost effective, since it would allow establishment of cross-organisation licence agreements. The minor difference in the total costs estimates for the six-year cycle between the two documents largely reflects this change in who should be responsible for the costs of data licences.
Finally, all revisions to figures were based on close discussion with, and information from, SEPA.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S3W-25987 by reference.