Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026

Written Question · S3W-14583 · Session 3

What progress has been made in its discussions with the UK Government on addressing the consequences of the Somerville judgment for human r…

Answered Asked by Nigel Don SNP Lodged 24 Jun 2008

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive what progress has been made in its discussions with the UK Government on addressing the consequences of the Somerville judgment for human rights claims against the Scottish Ministers.

The answer

Answered by Kenny MacAskill on 25 Jun 2008 · 1 day after it was lodged, on time

The answer to question S3W-6286 on 14 November 2007 described the legal impact of the Somerville judgement both in relation to slopping out in prisons and more generally, as well as the action that the Scottish Government was taking to remedy the prison conditions we inherited from the previous administration and that had led to that judgement. Given the terms of the judgement and the current state of the law we have no option but to settle outstanding court cases and subsequent claims for compensation from others detained in similar conditions for a material period of time, subject to any general provisions on prescription and limitation of claims and delay.
We have therefore acted to deal with the immediate consequences of the judgement. As at 16 May 2008, the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) had settled 1,093 court cases and 1,325 compensation claims submitted under the administrative scheme set up to consider slopping out claims without the need to go to court. The SPS has paid out £5.1 million in compensation and £2.6 million in associated legal fees. A further 600 cases are under offer and another 740 have yet to be considered. New claims are being received at the rate of 260 per week and are being dealt with as quickly as possible.
That still leaves the question of how to deal with the fundamental legal issue that it raised, namely that the Scottish ministers are the only public authority exposed to claims for damages arising from alleged breaches of human rights without a one-year time bar.
When the Somerville judgement was delivered in October 2007, I made clear to the UK Government that we considered that situation to be untenable and unacceptable. I therefore sought early discussions with the UK Government to discuss the judgement’s implications and how the anomaly it created could be addressed. In particular, I proposed that the UK Government should introduce legislation to apply to claims against the Scottish ministers the same one-year time bar under the Human Rights Act as applies in other claims under the act. Since this concerns a reserved matter, such legislation would require the agreement of the UK government even though the problem to be remedied is a purely Scottish one.
Some constructive discussions with the UK Government at both ministerial and official level have since taken place. However, I regret to report that we have not so far secured agreement by the UK Government to our request that they should take action to remedy the situation, whether by amendment of the Scotland Act or by giving the Parliament the power to do so itself. This is disappointing, especially given the seriousness of this issue and the initial indications we received that they would consider our approach positively and promptly. Nevertheless, our discussions are continuing. In the meantime, I have made clear to the UK Government my disappointment that this issue remains unresolved, and reiterated that I look forward to hearing from them as soon as possible with substantive proposals. I will continue to keep the Parliament advised of developments.
All answers to written parliamentary questions are available on the Parliament’s website, the search facility for which can be found at http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/webapp/wa.search.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S3W-14583 by reference.