Written Question · S3W-06286 · Session 3
What the consequences of the Somerville judgment will be for the actions currently before the court raised by prisoners and ex-prisoners an…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive what the consequences of the Somerville judgment will be for the actions currently before the court raised by prisoners and ex-prisoners and how the Scottish Government will respond.
The answer
As a government weare determined to deal with both the causes and effects of the court actions wehave inherited relating to slopping out. I have today confirmed that the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) will invest on average £120 million a year tobuild long-needed replacement prisons in the north-east and Bishopbriggs andend the conditions that leave the system open to these claims.
Slopping out wasfirst held by the Scottish courts to be in breach of the European Convention onHuman Rights in Napier, a case relating to prison conditions going back to 1999and decided in 2004.
Further actionsin the Court of Session and the sheriff court were sisted pending the outcomeof the House of Lords decision in the related case of Somerville.
In September 2006the then Scottish Executive made a concession in the light of European Court ofHuman Rights jurisprudence to settle claims where prisoners had been detained ina shared cell with no access to in-cell sanitation. Offers of settlement werelimited to those cases which then fell within the Scottish Executive’sinterpretation of the time bar in human rights cases. The Scottish PrisonService at that time made provision in its accounts against the possibility offurther successful claims.
On 24 October2007 the House of Lords ruled that the Scotland Act 1998 does not provide anexplicit time bar for human rights claims brought against Scottish ministers.
In the light ofthis ruling we have concluded that we have no option but to settle outstandingcourt cases where an individual has been detained in the relevant conditionsfor a material period of time, subject to any general provisions onprescription and limitation of claims and delay. To continue to defend thesecases would incur further costs for no public benefit. The cases will besettled using the provision previously made in SPS’s accounts.
The effect of theHouse of Lords ruling is to leave the Scottish Government as the only publicauthority exposed to claims of this kind without a one year time bar. I havemade it clear to the UK Government that I regard that position as untenable andunacceptable and that action is required to restore the position to what webelieve was intended in 1998 and was understood to be case before now. If thatrequires amendment of the Scotland Act, I believe the UK Government should beprepared to consider bringing forward legislation to that effect. I continue todiscuss these points with the UK Government and will give further details toParliament in due course.
Slopping out wasfirst held by the Scottish courts to be in breach of the European Convention onHuman Rights in Napier, a case relating to prison conditions going back to 1999and decided in 2004.
Further actionsin the Court of Session and the sheriff court were sisted pending the outcomeof the House of Lords decision in the related case of Somerville.
In September 2006the then Scottish Executive made a concession in the light of European Court ofHuman Rights jurisprudence to settle claims where prisoners had been detained ina shared cell with no access to in-cell sanitation. Offers of settlement werelimited to those cases which then fell within the Scottish Executive’sinterpretation of the time bar in human rights cases. The Scottish PrisonService at that time made provision in its accounts against the possibility offurther successful claims.
On 24 October2007 the House of Lords ruled that the Scotland Act 1998 does not provide anexplicit time bar for human rights claims brought against Scottish ministers.
In the light ofthis ruling we have concluded that we have no option but to settle outstandingcourt cases where an individual has been detained in the relevant conditionsfor a material period of time, subject to any general provisions onprescription and limitation of claims and delay. To continue to defend thesecases would incur further costs for no public benefit. The cases will besettled using the provision previously made in SPS’s accounts.
The effect of theHouse of Lords ruling is to leave the Scottish Government as the only publicauthority exposed to claims of this kind without a one year time bar. I havemade it clear to the UK Government that I regard that position as untenable andunacceptable and that action is required to restore the position to what webelieve was intended in 1998 and was understood to be case before now. If thatrequires amendment of the Scotland Act, I believe the UK Government should beprepared to consider bringing forward legislation to that effect. I continue todiscuss these points with the UK Government and will give further details toParliament in due course.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S3W-06286 by reference.