Written Question · S3W-06176 · Session 3
Whether it considers that further research into an association between the incidence of congenital defects and proximity to landfill sites …
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive whether it considers that further research into an association between the incidence of congenital defects and proximity to landfill sites should be undertaken and, if so, what steps it will take to promote such research, in light of a significant association found by the Nant-Y-Gwyddon study (Fielder et al 1997) and the Eurohazcon Study (Dolk et al 1998).
The answer
Since thepublication of these studies, the UK Government has commissioned the Small Area Health Statistics Unit(SAHSU) at Imperial College to carry out a national study of congenital anomalies in populationsliving near to landfill sites (Elliott et al, British Medical Journal2001; 323: 363-8).
This study found a small increase in congenitalanomalies in populations living close to landfill sites but no causal linkbetween landfill sites and birth defects was established. In fact, for babiesborn to mothers living within 2km of a landfill site in Scotland,the overall reported rate of congenital anomalies was 6 per cent lower nearlandfills. The independent expert Committee on Toxicity of Chemicals in Food,Consumer Products and the Environment (COT) reviewed the findings and advisedthat, given the various inconsistencies, it is inappropriate to draw firmconclusions from the results. The SAHSU subsequently specifically analysed thedata on birth outcomes in populations living near "special waste"landfill sites in Scotland, and published their findings under the title Noexcess risk of adverse birth outcomes in populations living near special wastelandfill sites in Scotland (Morris et al, Scottish Medical Journal 2003;48: 105-107).
The ScottishGovernment Health Directorates have no plans to commission further studies inthis area.
This study found a small increase in congenitalanomalies in populations living close to landfill sites but no causal linkbetween landfill sites and birth defects was established. In fact, for babiesborn to mothers living within 2km of a landfill site in Scotland,the overall reported rate of congenital anomalies was 6 per cent lower nearlandfills. The independent expert Committee on Toxicity of Chemicals in Food,Consumer Products and the Environment (COT) reviewed the findings and advisedthat, given the various inconsistencies, it is inappropriate to draw firmconclusions from the results. The SAHSU subsequently specifically analysed thedata on birth outcomes in populations living near "special waste"landfill sites in Scotland, and published their findings under the title Noexcess risk of adverse birth outcomes in populations living near special wastelandfill sites in Scotland (Morris et al, Scottish Medical Journal 2003;48: 105-107).
The ScottishGovernment Health Directorates have no plans to commission further studies inthis area.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S3W-06176 by reference.