Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S3W-04570 · Session 3

When it will make a decision about the future of the following community justice pilot schemes: community reparation orders, bail with elec…

Answered Asked by Nigel Don SNP Lodged 25 Sep 2007

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive when it will make a decision about the future of the following community justice pilot schemes: community reparation orders, bail with electronic monitoring, first instance supervised attendance orders and structured deferred sentences.

The answer

Answered by Kenny MacAskill on 26 Sep 2007 · 1 day after it was lodged, on time

The evaluation of the Community Reparation Order (CRO) pilots indicates that the penalties were notwell understood or used, and we have therefore decided that the funding for theCRO pilots should stop at the end of December. The government remains committedto the principle of reparation, and as part of the review of community penaltieswe are currently considering the way in which reparative sentencing options as awhole are structured, with a view to proposing a more straightforward structurethat will be simpler to understand and more attractive to sentencers.
Independent evaluationof the electronic monitoring of bail pilots showed that this particular model ofoversight while on bail was little used and of limited effectiveness. We have thereforealso agreed that funding of the electronic monitoring of bail pilots should stopat the end of December. We believe that work currently under way to strengthen bailsupervision will give a more effective and more widely used set of options for thecourts.
In order to allowthe respective evaluations to be finalised, we have decided that funding for theStructured Deferred Sentences pilots should continue until the end of March 2008and funding for first instance Supervised Attendance Orders should continue fora further 12 months, until the end of October 2008.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S3W-04570 by reference.