Written Question · S2W-27115 · Session 2
Further to the answer to question S2W-26773 by Rhona Brankin on 23 June 2006, how many bulls were considered to have poor estimated breedin…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-26773 by Rhona Brankin on 23 June 2006, how many bulls were considered to have poor estimated breeding value in (a) 2004, (b) 2005 and (c) 2006, broken down by breed.
The answer
Information on cattlebreeding values over the 2004-2006 period is not available.
The following table showsthe percentage of bulls within each of the four breeds within the stud (for whichwe have information) which fall into the top 10%, top 25%, below average and bottom10% of their breed. This is calculated for two key factors; Beef Value andCalving Value.
Table: Beef and CalvingValue Rating of the Scheme Bulls in relation to 2002 Breed Averages
| Charolais
| Aberdeen Angus
| Limousin
| Simmental
| Overall 4 breeds
Beef Value
Top 10%
| 14%
| 14%
| 20%
| 30%
| 20%
Top 25%
| 43%
| 51%
| 40%
| 60%
| 45%
Below Average
| 50%
| 32%
| 35%
| 30%
| 35%
Bottom 10%
| 21%
| 5%
| 4%
| 0
| 5%
Calving Value
Top 10%
| 7%
| 22%
| 15%
| 13%
| 15%
Top 25%
| 21%
| 43%
| 31%
| 27%
| 32%
Below Average
|
79%
|
54%
|
67%
|
73%
|
67%
Bottom 10%
| 14%
| 16%
| 27%
| 27%
| 24%
Beef value is generallyabove
The following table showsthe percentage of bulls within each of the four breeds within the stud (for whichwe have information) which fall into the top 10%, top 25%, below average and bottom10% of their breed. This is calculated for two key factors; Beef Value andCalving Value.
Table: Beef and CalvingValue Rating of the Scheme Bulls in relation to 2002 Breed Averages
| Charolais
| Aberdeen Angus
| Limousin
| Simmental
| Overall 4 breeds
Beef Value
Top 10%
| 14%
| 14%
| 20%
| 30%
| 20%
Top 25%
| 43%
| 51%
| 40%
| 60%
| 45%
Below Average
| 50%
| 32%
| 35%
| 30%
| 35%
Bottom 10%
| 21%
| 5%
| 4%
| 0
| 5%
Calving Value
Top 10%
| 7%
| 22%
| 15%
| 13%
| 15%
Top 25%
| 21%
| 43%
| 31%
| 27%
| 32%
Below Average
|
79%
|
54%
|
67%
|
73%
|
67%
Bottom 10%
| 14%
| 16%
| 27%
| 27%
| 24%
Beef value is generallyabove
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-27115 by reference.