Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S2W-24561 · Session 2

Further to the answer to question S2W-23237 by Lewis Macdonald on 14 March 2006, whether the answer is consistent with the convention that …

Answered Asked by Kenny MacAskill SNP Lodged 22 Mar 2006

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-23237 by Lewis Macdonald on 14 March 2006, whether the answer is consistent with the convention that ministers should be as open as possible with the Parliament and the public, in light of instances where tribunals have not held required hearings, such as those referred to by the Administration of the Mental Health Tribunal of Scotland in the case of the petition of John Smith, Mental Health Officer for Fife Council, for judicial review of the Mental Health Tribunal.

The answer

Answered by Lewis Macdonald on 20 Apr 2006 · 29 days after it was lodged, on time

The answer given in responseto S2W-23237 was factually correct, and reflected the fact that the tribunal hasalways arranged hearings when required to do so. At the time of the question onno occasion had the Mental Health Tribunal failed to hold a hearing to examine anapplication for a Compulsory Treatment Order, either because of the lack of availabilityof a panel or for any other reason, and that remains the case. The Mental HealthTribunal has held a hearing to consider every valid application for a CompulsoryTreatment Order received to date. Eighteen cases have been heard outwith the statutorytimescales provided in the act: 14 due to errors of interpretation made by MentalHealth Officers in the completion of applications; one due to an administrativeerror by the Tribunal, and three where the applications were received on the dateof expiry of the original Short Term Detention Certificates and the tribunal consideredit did not have time to arrange a Hearing within the statutory timescales. In allcases hearings were arranged as soon as possible but after the expiry of the respectiveShort-Term Detention Certificates. Following a Judicial Review the Tribunal policyof not arranging immediate Hearings for applications received late in the 28 dayperiod of the Short-Term Detention Certificate has now been changed so that whena venue is not available within the required timescales the Hearing will be heldat the next nearest available venue, or if that is not suitable at the TribunalSuite in Bothwell House, Hamilton.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-24561 by reference.