Written Question · S2W-24474 · Session 2
Further to the answer to question S2W-23831 by Cathy Jamieson on 16 March 2006 where it states that it “has not approved and will not appro…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-23831 by Cathy Jamieson on 16 March 2006 where it states that it “has not approved and will not approve a policy of facilitating the transfer of individuals through Scottish territory or airspace to places where there are substantial grounds to believe that they would face a real risk of torture”, whether it will now discuss with Her Majesty’s Government the matter of CIA flights landing in Scotland, given that the original question did not pertain to whether it granted permission for such transfers to occur through Scotland but whether it would establish whether they happened at all.
The answer
Officials have discussed withUK Government Departments the allegations that Scottish airports have been usedfor the transportation of US prisoners to countries where they might be subjectedto torture (so-called “extraordinary rendition”). The position remains as set outin my response to question S2W-20910, answered on 7 December 2005. All answers towritten parliamentary questions are available on the Parliament’s website, the searchfacility for which can be found at http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/webapp/wa.search.
Since then, the Foreign Secretaryset out the UK Government’s position in detail in a Written Ministerial Statement on 20 January 2006, including that:
The UK Government found no evidenceof detainees being rendered through the UK or Overseas Territories since 11 September 2001.
It found no evidence of detaineesbeing rendered through the UK or Overseas Territories since 1997 where there were substantial grounds to believethere was a real risk of torture.
There were four cases in 1998where the US requested permission to render one or more detaineesthrough the UK or Overseas Territories. Records show the Government granted the US request intwo of these cases, and refused the request in the other two.
The Government is clear thatthe US would not render a detainee through UK territory or airspace (includingOverseas Territories) without the UK Government’s permission.
In one of the two 1998 cases,in June 1998, a flight carrying Mohammed Rashid landed at Prestwick en route tothe United States, where he was due to stand trial. He was charged for bombing aPan Am aircraft in August 1982. He pleaded guilty to murder in December 2002 andis due to be sentenced shortly.
Since then, the Foreign Secretaryset out the UK Government’s position in detail in a Written Ministerial Statement on 20 January 2006, including that:
The UK Government found no evidenceof detainees being rendered through the UK or Overseas Territories since 11 September 2001.
It found no evidence of detaineesbeing rendered through the UK or Overseas Territories since 1997 where there were substantial grounds to believethere was a real risk of torture.
There were four cases in 1998where the US requested permission to render one or more detaineesthrough the UK or Overseas Territories. Records show the Government granted the US request intwo of these cases, and refused the request in the other two.
The Government is clear thatthe US would not render a detainee through UK territory or airspace (includingOverseas Territories) without the UK Government’s permission.
In one of the two 1998 cases,in June 1998, a flight carrying Mohammed Rashid landed at Prestwick en route tothe United States, where he was due to stand trial. He was charged for bombing aPan Am aircraft in August 1982. He pleaded guilty to murder in December 2002 andis due to be sentenced shortly.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-24474 by reference.