Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S2W-23970 · Session 2

Whether it will list all the investigations and inquiries that it has initiated since January 1997 in relation to, or arising from, the Shi…

Answered Asked by Alex Neil SNP Lodged 7 Mar 2006

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will list all the investigations and inquiries that it has initiated since January 1997 in relation to, or arising from, the Shirley McKie case and, for each investigation or inquiry, (a) what the remit was, (b) who carried it out, (c) how long it took, (d) to whom it reported, (e) how much it cost, (f) what conclusions and recommendations it reached and (g) which recommendations have been (i) implemented and (ii) not implemented.

The answer

Answered by Cathy Jamieson on 3 Apr 2006 · 27 days after it was lodged, 13 days after it was due

There have been a number ofinvestigations into the Shirley McKie case.
The SCRO Executive Committeedecided in February 2000 to invite HMIC to bring forward a planned inspectionof SCRO. This resulted in the HMIC Primary Inspection of the SCRO FingerprintBureau which began on 20 March 2000. The Inspection Report was published on 14 September 2000.It contained 25 recommendations and 20 suggestions. The recommendations andsuggestions were discharged in the HMIC SCRO Primary Inspection Report 2004that was published on 17 March 2005.
In response to the emergingfindings of the HMIC Inspection of 2000, on 21 June 2000ACPOS set up an ACPOS Presidential Review Group (APRG) to coordinate the ScottishPolice Service’s response. A Change Management Review Team (CMRT) was appointedto undertake a 90-day scrutiny of the SCRO Fingerprint Bureau. Its report waspublished in October 2000 and contained 87 findings. By 10 March 2006,82 findings had been discharged and progress was being made on completingthe work necessary to discharge the others.
In June 2000, ACPOS askedsenior officers of Tayside police
- Deputy Chief Constable Mackay and ChiefSuperintendent Robertson
- to investigate the discrepancy between the findingsof the SCRO experts and those of experts who were instructed by ACPOS duringtheir earlier review. The Lord Advocate then instructed the Regional Procurator Fiscal forNorth Strathclyde to inquire into allegations of criminality, specificallyperjury. The inquiry by Tayside officers was then widened to investigate thatallegation and was asked to report its findings to the regional procuratorfiscal. That inquiry was extended again in September 2000 to cover similarallegations in the Asbury case.
In October 2000, the Taysideofficers submitted their report to ACPOS for its interest and to the RegionalProcurator Fiscal for his. They then made further inquiries to assist the RegionalProcurator Fiscal's investigation. The Regional Procurator Fiscalsubmitted his report to the Crown Office in July 2001. The Lord Advocateconsidered that report, and all of the available evidence and decided thatthere should be no prosecution.
In September 2001Strathclyde Joint Police Board (the employer of the 4 fingerprint officers)established an ad hoc investigation and disciplinary procedure. This work wastaken forward under the auspices of an Independent Scrutiny Committee and an investigatingo fficer was appointed. The chair of the Committee advised the Clerk to theJoint Police Board on 20 March 2002 that the Investigating Officer had concluded thatthe officers should be returned to their normal duties, and that the ScrutinyCommittee endorsed his report.
My letter of 10 March 2006 tothe Convenor of the Justice 1 Committee provides more information about HMICPrimary Inspection 2000 and the CMRT report. This is at:
http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/business/committees/justice1/papers-06/Correspondence_Minister_for_Justice_10_March_2006.pdf.
It is not be possible toestablish the costs of these inquiries.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-23970 by reference.