Written Question · S2W-23632 · Session 2
Whether it agrees with the Scottish Prisons Complaints Commissioner that the pre-recorded message on all outgoing calls from Scottish priso…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive whether it agrees with the Scottish Prisons Complaints Commissioner that the pre-recorded message on all outgoing calls from Scottish prisoners should be removed or reworded; whether it is aware that in England similar pre-recorded messages have been removed; when it will take action on this issue, and whether it has sought legal advice with regard to a possible challenge under human rights legislation.
The answer
I have asked Tony Cameron, Chief Executive of the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) to respond. His response is as follows:
The current message, which precedesany call from a prisoner, advises recipients that the call is coming from a prison.The SPS believes that the message provides the public, for example victims or vulnerablewitnesses with some safeguard against unwanted calls. The SPS also considers thatthe message is necessary and legal. In his most recent report, the Prison ComplaintsCommissioner noted that SPS had “taken legal advice on this matter and concludedthat any interference that the pre-recorded message caused to a prisoner’s privacyrights was justifiable and thus permissible under Article 8 of the Convention.
The current message, which precedesany call from a prisoner, advises recipients that the call is coming from a prison.The SPS believes that the message provides the public, for example victims or vulnerablewitnesses with some safeguard against unwanted calls. The SPS also considers thatthe message is necessary and legal. In his most recent report, the Prison ComplaintsCommissioner noted that SPS had “taken legal advice on this matter and concludedthat any interference that the pre-recorded message caused to a prisoner’s privacyrights was justifiable and thus permissible under Article 8 of the Convention.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-23632 by reference.