Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026

Written Question · S2W-23158 · Session 2

Further to the statement made by the then Minister for Justice on 22 June 2000 on the Scottish Criminal Records Office (Official Report, c.…

Answered Asked by Alex Neil SNP Lodged 10 Feb 2006

The question

To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the statement made by the then Minister for Justice on 22 June 2000 on the Scottish Criminal Records Office (Official Report, c. 681) what the conclusions and outcome were of the report commissioned.

The answer

Answered by Cathy Jamieson on 17 Feb 2006 · 7 days after it was lodged, on time

The then Deputy FirstMinister and Minister for Justice’s statement concerned an inspection of the ScottishCriminal Record Office (SCRO) Fingerprint Bureau by Her Majesty’s ChiefInspector of Constabulary (HMIC). The inspection began on 20 March 2000. On 22 June 2000 HMICpublished an interim report in which he explained that expert advice given tohim by Independent fingerprint experts was to the effect that the latent markin the case was not that of Shirley McKie and that in his view the SCRO FingerprintBureau was “not fully effective and efficient”.
In his statement the Deputy First Ministermade clear that the Scottish Executive would support the ACPOS PresidentialReview which took responsibility for implementing HMIC’s recommendations. Healso indicated that the ACPOS Presidential Review would consider the positionof the four fingerprint officers concerned.
In a statement on the sameday the Lord Advocate indicated that an independent external check wouldbe carried out in all current and future cases where fingerprint evidence wassubmitted by SCRO. In July 2001 the Lord Advocate decided that independentverification of SCRO fingerprint evidence was no longer required. In theprevious 13 months over 1,700 cases were reviewed and in each case the accuracyof the identification was confirmed.
In August 2000, thePresident of ACPOS and the Chairman of SCRO’s Executive Committee concludedthat the four members of staff should be suspended on a precautionary basis. Anad hoc investigation and disciplinary procedure was carried out and inMarch 2002 the SCRO Scrutiny Committee announced that no disciplinary actionwould be taken. The four officers returned to work in on 9 April 2002 on aphased return basis, moving to full-time working from March 2003.
The full HMIC report ScottishCriminal Record Office: The Fingerprint Bureau Primary Inspection 2000 (availableon the Scottish Executive website) contained 25 recommendations and 20suggestions and was published on 14 September 2000. The recommendationscovered a range of issues including the need for improvements in training,testing and quality assurance measures, consideration of a national fingerprintservice, move towards the introduction of a different evidential standard forfingerprints in Scotland, strengthening the administrative support for thefingerprint service and setting up a task force to take forward the changesrecommended. All of the recommendations and suggestions have been successfully implemented.
Following therecommendations in this report and the ACPOS Presidential Review, the SCROExecutive Committee, senior management at SCRO and the Scottish Executive haveput in place an extensive programme of change management.
This has included:
Appointing a Head ofScottish Fingerprint Service in April 2001 to lead the work to establish the Scottish Fingerprint Service (SFS) based on 4 bureaux in Glasgow, Edinburgh, Dundee and Aberdeen.The model was approved in principle by the SCRO Executive Committee in June2001 and rationalisation of the existing structure commenced. This work wascompleted in early 2002;
Relocating SCRO and the Glasgowfingerprint bureau from Strathclyde Police Headquarters to Pacific Quay. Thiswas intended to help create a distinct and independent corporate identity forSCRO and the SFS;
The SFS uses theinternationally accepted process of identification which conforms to thescientific principles of analyse, compare, evaluate, verify (ACE V) withverification by two fingerprint experts following the initial expertidentification. Enhanced independent verification was introduced. Only afterthe independent verification procedure is complete will an identification beintimated to the police investigating officer and the Procurator Fiscal Servicefor their consideration in any court proceedings;
Quality assurance andtraining officers have been in post at Aberdeen, Dundee and Edinburgh bureaux since 2002

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-23158 by reference.