Written Question · S2W-22946 · Session 2
Further to the answers to questions S2W-21779 and S2W-22555 by Mr Andy Kerr on 19 and 30 January 2006, what the outcome was of the meeting …
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answers to questions S2W-21779 and S2W-22555 by Mr Andy Kerr on 19 and 30 January 2006, what the outcome was of the meeting between Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs, UK Health Departments, the Department for Education and Skills, NHS Employers and the University and Colleges Employers Association on 31 January 2006 in respect of the Court of the University of Glasgow ruling on the form of contract for clinical academic posts and when and where the minutes of that meeting will be published.
The answer
Health Department officials representingthe Executive attended the meeting. The outcome was that a Memorandum of Understandingis to be written to clarify the employment arrangements that exist between NHS bodiesand Universities, with a view to confirming that they constitute joint employmentarrangements that are outwith the scope of VAT.
The group is aiming to preparethe Memorandum of Understanding and negotiate with the unions by the end of March.
Minutes of such meetings arenot usually published but the following are the action notes that were circulatedto attendees and guidance to NHS bodies will follow agreement of the Memorandumof Understanding.
Action Notes of Meeting to DiscussVAT on Clinical Academic Salaries
31 January 2006
Mezzanine Room, Woburn House,Tavistock Square, London
Present:
Nic Greenfield, DH (Chair)
Martin Shaw, Guy’s and St ThomasKatie Petty-Saphon, CHMS
Steve Large, BUFDG
Eve Jagusiewicz, UUK
Sharron Powley, UCEA
Diane Gillhooley, Eversheds
Chris Cardwell, NHS Employers
Amerjit Basi, DfES
Phil Sears, HMRC
Cathy Smith, HMRC
Paul Tuckett, HMRC
Vicky Cave, DH
Anne Rylatt, DH
Anita James, SOL Employment
Jane Davidson, Scotland
Lee Sheddon, Scotland.
Apologies:
David Ogilvie, HMRC, Prof JanetFinch, UUK, Sir Jonathan Michael, AUKUH.
5. The meeting opened with introductions.It was agreed that the purpose of the meeting was to seek a practical and legalsolution to the VAT implications of the Glasgow tribunal case.
6. Vicky Cave brieflyoutlined the University of Glasgow Tribunal case and the financial pressures this had created forthe NHS. Paul Tuckett provided further detail on the definitions of supplies ofstaff and services and how these related to the contractual status of clinical academics.
7. Paul Tuckett outlined thekey criteria which had to be met in contracts if they were to be considered jointfor VAT purposes (and therefore outside the scope of VAT).
i. Each employer must recognisethe status, rights and responsibilities of the other employer.
ii. Each employer must fulfilits obligations and rights as an employer.
iii. Employees must acknowledgeand observe their rights and responsibilities to both employers.
iv. The number of contracts isirrelevant.
v. Substance takes precedenceover legal form.
vi. It does not matter if oneemployer acts as sole paymaster, pensions administrator etc. provided broadly appropriatecosts are recharged to the other.
8. It was asserted that mostof these points were clear within the current contractual framework, and that anEmployment Tribunal would have found that there were two employers.
9. Discussion followed on thepaymaster function. The following issues were important:
There would be one salary slipand one payroll.
It is irrelevant who administersthe pay as long as there is an appropriate recharge for the other employer’s share.
The contributions of the individualemployers need not be shown on the salary slip.
The recharge could be agreedat organisational level, built up from individual level data.
Membership of a single pensionscheme is permissible although the recharge would include appropriate pension contributions.
10. Discussion followed on thepractical difficulties of addressing the paymaster issue within contracts.
11. All agreed that joint jobplanning formed a reasonable basis for agreeing the level of recharge. It wouldbe impractical to monitor beyond this. A global assessment of recharge which was“broadly appropriate” would follow. This approach was acceptable to HMRC.
12. The meeting went on to discussin detail the wording in the substantive and honorary contracts for Senior AcademicGPs as a model for types of contract in place.
13. Difficulties which requiredclarification were identified around:
The group is aiming to preparethe Memorandum of Understanding and negotiate with the unions by the end of March.
Minutes of such meetings arenot usually published but the following are the action notes that were circulatedto attendees and guidance to NHS bodies will follow agreement of the Memorandumof Understanding.
Action Notes of Meeting to DiscussVAT on Clinical Academic Salaries
31 January 2006
Mezzanine Room, Woburn House,Tavistock Square, London
Present:
Nic Greenfield, DH (Chair)
Martin Shaw, Guy’s and St ThomasKatie Petty-Saphon, CHMS
Steve Large, BUFDG
Eve Jagusiewicz, UUK
Sharron Powley, UCEA
Diane Gillhooley, Eversheds
Chris Cardwell, NHS Employers
Amerjit Basi, DfES
Phil Sears, HMRC
Cathy Smith, HMRC
Paul Tuckett, HMRC
Vicky Cave, DH
Anne Rylatt, DH
Anita James, SOL Employment
Jane Davidson, Scotland
Lee Sheddon, Scotland.
Apologies:
David Ogilvie, HMRC, Prof JanetFinch, UUK, Sir Jonathan Michael, AUKUH.
5. The meeting opened with introductions.It was agreed that the purpose of the meeting was to seek a practical and legalsolution to the VAT implications of the Glasgow tribunal case.
6. Vicky Cave brieflyoutlined the University of Glasgow Tribunal case and the financial pressures this had created forthe NHS. Paul Tuckett provided further detail on the definitions of supplies ofstaff and services and how these related to the contractual status of clinical academics.
7. Paul Tuckett outlined thekey criteria which had to be met in contracts if they were to be considered jointfor VAT purposes (and therefore outside the scope of VAT).
i. Each employer must recognisethe status, rights and responsibilities of the other employer.
ii. Each employer must fulfilits obligations and rights as an employer.
iii. Employees must acknowledgeand observe their rights and responsibilities to both employers.
iv. The number of contracts isirrelevant.
v. Substance takes precedenceover legal form.
vi. It does not matter if oneemployer acts as sole paymaster, pensions administrator etc. provided broadly appropriatecosts are recharged to the other.
8. It was asserted that mostof these points were clear within the current contractual framework, and that anEmployment Tribunal would have found that there were two employers.
9. Discussion followed on thepaymaster function. The following issues were important:
There would be one salary slipand one payroll.
It is irrelevant who administersthe pay as long as there is an appropriate recharge for the other employer’s share.
The contributions of the individualemployers need not be shown on the salary slip.
The recharge could be agreedat organisational level, built up from individual level data.
Membership of a single pensionscheme is permissible although the recharge would include appropriate pension contributions.
10. Discussion followed on thepractical difficulties of addressing the paymaster issue within contracts.
11. All agreed that joint jobplanning formed a reasonable basis for agreeing the level of recharge. It wouldbe impractical to monitor beyond this. A global assessment of recharge which was“broadly appropriate” would follow. This approach was acceptable to HMRC.
12. The meeting went on to discussin detail the wording in the substantive and honorary contracts for Senior AcademicGPs as a model for types of contract in place.
13. Difficulties which requiredclarification were identified around:
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-22946 by reference.