Written Question · S2W-18371 · Session 2
Further to the answer to question S2W-17655 by Mr Andy Kerr on 2 August 2005, what the reasons are for the discrepancy in the number of rec…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-17655 by Mr Andy Kerr on 2 August 2005, what the reasons are for the discrepancy in the number of recorded injuries between the “STATS 19” returns and the recorded injury number in the answer to the question for the same period.
The answer
The response to S2W-17655, answeredon 2 August 2005, related to admissions to hospital resulting from roadtraffic accidents. The STATS 19 report publishes data that cover all injury roadaccidents (i.e. accidents in which one or more people are injured) which becomeknown to the police in Scotland. Thus the two reports are not directly comparable. Police forces submit the STATS 19 returns, which give detailsof road accidents, in which one or more people were injured, which occurred on publicroads and which were reported to them. Many of the casualties in such accidentsare not injured sufficiently badly to be admitted to hospital
- so would not becounted in the hospital admissions figures There will also be accidents which resultin someone being admitted to hospital but which are not reported to the police.For example, a child who was badly injured when falling off a bike in the street,with no other vehicle being involved, might well be admitted to hospital (and recordedthere as a road accident casualty) without the police being informed
- so wouldnot be counted in the Stats 19 figures.
Road accident statisticsare available in Key 2004 Road Accident Statistics, (Bib. number 36730) andRoad Accidents Scotland 2003, (Bib. number 34523).
- so would not becounted in the hospital admissions figures There will also be accidents which resultin someone being admitted to hospital but which are not reported to the police.For example, a child who was badly injured when falling off a bike in the street,with no other vehicle being involved, might well be admitted to hospital (and recordedthere as a road accident casualty) without the police being informed
- so wouldnot be counted in the Stats 19 figures.
Road accident statisticsare available in Key 2004 Road Accident Statistics, (Bib. number 36730) andRoad Accidents Scotland 2003, (Bib. number 34523).
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-18371 by reference.