Written Question · S2W-15607 · Session 2
Whether the Lord Advocate will pursue criminal action against those who allegedly falsified the information relating to suicide watches in …
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive whether the Lord Advocate will pursue criminal action against those who allegedly falsified the information relating to suicide watches in HM Prison Kilmarnock, as reported in the BBC documentary broadcast on 9 March 2005 and in the findings of the fatal accident inquiry into the death of James Barclay in HM Prison Kilmarnock in January 2002 when it was stated in evidence that such watch logs were falsified regularly.
The answer
I refer the member to the answer to question S2W-15477, answered on 18 April 2005. All answers to writtenparliamentary questions are available on the Parliament's website, the searchfacility for which can be found at http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/webapp/wa.search.
Ihave considered the findings of the fatal accident inquiry into the death ofJames Barclay in HM Prison Kilmarnock on 11 January 2002. Two prison officers gave evidenceat the Inquiry in relation to falsifying watch logs. Prior to them givingevidence, the Procurator Fiscal granted both officers immunity from any futurecriminal prosecution arising from the circumstances leading up to the death ofJames Barclay. He did this as he could not conceive of a situation whereby theywould face criminal charges arising from the circumstances surrounding thedeath of James Barclay, but wanted to ensure that the Inquiry received thefullest account possible of relevant events. Although it would not be open tothe Crown to bring criminal charges in light of that grant of immunity, theProcurator Fiscal was correct in concluding that there was no basis forcriminal proceedings against them.
In addition there is nobasis for criminal proceedings against those prison officers alleged, in termsof a BBC documentary, to have falsified information relating to suicide watchesin HM Prison Kilmarnock.
Ihave considered the findings of the fatal accident inquiry into the death ofJames Barclay in HM Prison Kilmarnock on 11 January 2002. Two prison officers gave evidenceat the Inquiry in relation to falsifying watch logs. Prior to them givingevidence, the Procurator Fiscal granted both officers immunity from any futurecriminal prosecution arising from the circumstances leading up to the death ofJames Barclay. He did this as he could not conceive of a situation whereby theywould face criminal charges arising from the circumstances surrounding thedeath of James Barclay, but wanted to ensure that the Inquiry received thefullest account possible of relevant events. Although it would not be open tothe Crown to bring criminal charges in light of that grant of immunity, theProcurator Fiscal was correct in concluding that there was no basis forcriminal proceedings against them.
In addition there is nobasis for criminal proceedings against those prison officers alleged, in termsof a BBC documentary, to have falsified information relating to suicide watchesin HM Prison Kilmarnock.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-15607 by reference.