Written Question · S2W-13392 · Session 2
Further to the answer to question S2W-4807 by Malcolm Chisholm on 19 January 2004, what the difference in median wait and mean wait was for…
The question
To ask the Scottish Executive, further to the answer to question S2W-4807 by Malcolm Chisholm on 19 January 2004, what the difference in median wait and mean wait was for the quarter ended (a) 31 December 2003, (b) 31 March 2004, (c) 30 June 2004 and (d) 30 September 2004.
The answer
The differences between the median wait and mean wait for in-patient/day case treatment and new out-patient appointments for the quarters ending: 31 December 2003, 31 March 2004, 30 June 2004 and 30 September 2004 were as follows:
Difference in Median and Mean Wait (Days)
| In-Patient/Day Case Waiting Time
| First Out-patient Appointment Waiting Time
Quarter Ended
| Median
| Mean
| Difference
| Median
| Mean
| Difference
31-Dec-03
| 40
| 83.2
| -43.2
| 53
| 87.8
| -34.8
31-Mar-04
| 43
| 83.0
| -40.0
| 54
| 89.5
| -35.5
30-Jun-04P
| 41
| 78.5
| -37.5
| 51
| 85.6
| -34.6
30-Sep-04P
| 43
| 81.3
| -38.3
| 55
| 89.8
| -34.8
PProvisional.
Sources: ISD, SMR00 & SMR01.
The distributions of both out-patients and in-patients/day cases and outpatients are very skewed making the median the more appropriate measure. The mean is highly sensitive to the small number of unusually high values in the long tail of the distribution. A significant number of those waiting for a long time will have been delayed due to failing to attend, cancelling an offer of anappointment or having medical/social constraints that prevent admission fortreatment.
Neither the mean nor the median are targets for NHSScotland and they are only summary measures for patients awaiting in-patient/day case hospital care where reducing maximum waiting times is the Scottish Executive’s priority. They take no account of the annual 465,000 emergency admissions, where patients are admitted immediately and they take no account of the annual 26.5 million face-to-face contacts with the primary care team.
Difference in Median and Mean Wait (Days)
| In-Patient/Day Case Waiting Time
| First Out-patient Appointment Waiting Time
Quarter Ended
| Median
| Mean
| Difference
| Median
| Mean
| Difference
31-Dec-03
| 40
| 83.2
| -43.2
| 53
| 87.8
| -34.8
31-Mar-04
| 43
| 83.0
| -40.0
| 54
| 89.5
| -35.5
30-Jun-04P
| 41
| 78.5
| -37.5
| 51
| 85.6
| -34.6
30-Sep-04P
| 43
| 81.3
| -38.3
| 55
| 89.8
| -34.8
PProvisional.
Sources: ISD, SMR00 & SMR01.
The distributions of both out-patients and in-patients/day cases and outpatients are very skewed making the median the more appropriate measure. The mean is highly sensitive to the small number of unusually high values in the long tail of the distribution. A significant number of those waiting for a long time will have been delayed due to failing to attend, cancelling an offer of anappointment or having medical/social constraints that prevent admission fortreatment.
Neither the mean nor the median are targets for NHSScotland and they are only summary measures for patients awaiting in-patient/day case hospital care where reducing maximum waiting times is the Scottish Executive’s priority. They take no account of the annual 465,000 emergency admissions, where patients are admitted immediately and they take no account of the annual 26.5 million face-to-face contacts with the primary care team.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S2W-13392 by reference.